Tag Archives: Susan Sontag

NOT A MAN, BUT A “MAN”

Roy Lichtenstein, the Whitney, and the joke inside the hero

In 1963 a former Army draftsman painted one jet destroying another, and took the picture from a panel in a twelve-cent war comic, drawn by a man who later said he had been the draftsman’s officer. This season the Whitney hangs more than 130 of his works under the title Like New, and The New Yorker’s review says the best of them aim their camp wit at masculinity. The heroes, in other words, are in quotation marks. What about the men who drew them?

Issue 89 of All-American Men of War, cover-dated February 1962 and priced at twelve cents, has somewhere in its middle a panel in which a jet fires a rocket at another jet, drawn by Irving Novick. Thirty-six years later, when Roy Lichtenstein had been dead a year and that panel had become the most famous explosion in American painting, Novick told a story about him: that he, a comics man from the Bronx trained at the National Academy of Design, had been the superior officer who heard a tearful draftee named Lichtenstein complain about his menial work and got him a better job. The retellings have since handed the draftee a mop. The story has problems. Novick placed it in 1947, by which time Lichtenstein had been out of the Army for a year and Novick was drawing a newspaper strip called Cynthia. It rests on Novick’s word alone, and the comics scholar Bart Beaty reads it as an old man’s attempt to make a famous one smaller. It is still the right story to carry up to the Whitney’s fifth floor this winter, because it holds in miniature everything the show is about: a man copying a man, a hero drawn by hand and then drawn again, and the question of who, exactly, is being laughed at.

Roy Lichtenstein: Like New opened on October 11 and runs to May 10, 2027. It is the first major retrospective of his work in New York since the Guggenheim’s in 1993, and it was organized by the Whitney’s Meg Onli with the artist Alex Da Corte, whose studio has re-created the mural Lichtenstein made for the 1964 World’s Fair and who has painted anew his 1967 Super Sunset Billboard. Hilton Als, reviewing it in The New Yorker, writes that the show positions Lichtenstein as “the last happy white man in American art,” and allows that so much charm can tire a viewer as well as please one. The review’s headline and subtitle put its claim in a line worth an afternoon’s thought: that Lichtenstein’s best work aims its camp humor at gender stereotypes, and the headline names the target, masculinity.

The claim has a history of its own. Als was project editor of the catalogue for Black Male, Thelma Golden’s 1994 exhibition at the Whitney on the representation of masculinity, and he has spent most of the years since as a theater critic, where camp is a working tool rather than an insult. It reaches us under the byline of a critic who knows what a hero looks like in makeup. So take the claim seriously and walk it through the pictures: the pilot in the cockpit, the painter named Brad, the villain with the furious eyes, the hand that holds the brush, the caller on the other end of the line. If Lichtenstein put the American man in quotation marks, the question a curious reader wants answered is not whether the joke is funny. It is where the joke lands, given that the hero was drawn first, at a page rate, by men named Irv Novick and Russ Heath.

I The Lieutenant’s Panel

Inside that issue a story called “Star Jockey” had a panel by Novick in which a jet fires a rocket and another jet comes apart in flame, and the following year Lichtenstein made it into Whaam!, two canvases together more than thirteen feet wide, on the scale of the abstract expressionists’ canvases. He showed it at Leo Castelli’s gallery in 1963. The Tate bought it in 1966, and in Britain it has been the picture people think of when they hear his name ever since. He kept the jets, the rocket and the burst. He dropped the story. On the comics, he is quoted as saying that “the heroes depicted in comic books are fascist types, but I don’t take them seriously,” as allowing that there might be a political point in not taking them seriously, and then as saying he used them for purely formal reasons.

DC’s war comics fed him more than once, and the second artist is the one to watch. Panels by Russ Heath became Blam in 1962 and parts of Okay Hot-Shot, Okay! and Brattata in 1963. Heath lived to ninety-one. In his eighties he drew a six-panel strip about the business for the Hero Initiative, the charity that had helped pay for his knee surgery, and his line on the matter was plain. He believed part of the Whaam! panel was his, and the Tate’s own magazine has credited it to Novick and Heath together; of that painting he said Lichtenstein got four million dollars, and of himself, “I got zero.” The Tate agreed to pay a dealer £3,940 for the painting in 1966 and has kept it ever since, so whatever Heath meant by four million, nobody paid Lichtenstein that for it. Like Novick’s date, Heath’s figure is off, and off in the direction of the grievance. He said Lichtenstein at least owed him a drink. The men who drew the heroes, it turns out, had a sense of humor too, and it ran in the other direction.

Lichtenstein’s own war is worth setting beside the one they drew. He was drafted in 1943, at nineteen, out of Ohio State, and the Army put him through a sequence of studies and training programs it then cancelled, pilot training among them. He never flew. He served as an orderly and a draftsman, came home in early 1946 to a dying father, and went back to Ohio on the G.I. Bill to finish a degree his parents had wanted him to have in case he ever had to teach. Which he did, on and off for most of the next eighteen years, at Ohio State, in Oswego and at Rutgers, until he could stop. The pilot in Whaam!, then, is the man he was once put in training to become, drawn by men who drew such pilots for a living.

Look at how he painted that man. The pilot in Whaam! is a helmet in a canopy, no face to speak of; in Okay Hot-Shot the face is there but the mouth is a slot pouring out a sentence; in As I Opened Fire the voice narrates its own heroism in the past tense while the guns are still firing. Lichtenstein’s men are not characters. They are an announcer’s voice attached to a machine, and the machine does the acting. If there is a critique of masculinity in the war pictures, that is its form: the hero does not have a body, he has equipment, and he tells you what he did while he is doing it. Read this way, the joke is not cruel. It is the joke of an Army draftsman who never got off the ground.

II Brad, Darling

The year before Whaam! he painted a man from behind. In Masterpiece, from 1962, a blonde and a painter we see only as a dark head and a shoulder stand before a canvas, and her balloon tells him that the picture is a masterpiece and that all of New York will soon be clamoring for his work. His name, the balloon says, is Brad. Lichtenstein was thirty-eight that year and still teaching at Rutgers. His first Castelli show, that February, had sold out before it opened, and the painting is a joke about the artist as hero told by a man who had been one for about five minutes. It is also, as everyone now notes with a straight face, a picture that reportedly changed hands in 2017 for a hundred and sixty-five million dollars. Brad got his clamor. He still has his back to us.

The public clamor, when it came, was mostly hostile. A critic at The New York Times called him one of the worst artists in America, and on January 31, 1964, Life put the verdict into a headline as a question: “Is He the Worst Artist in the U.S.?” Lichtenstein’s own position, as it is usually reported, was that the nearer a picture stayed to its source, the more of a threat and a criticism it carried, which is either a serious theory of appropriation or the best deadpan in the history of the form.

And then there is the painting the show puts near its start. Image Duplicator, 1963, is a pair of furious eyes under a furrowed brow, lifted from the first issue of The X-Men, cover-dated September 1963, where they belonged to the villain Magneto as drawn by Jack Kirby and Paul Reinman; the Lichtenstein catalogue lists a second comic among the painting’s sources. The balloon above the eyes reads: “What? Why did you ask that? What do you know about my image duplicator?” It has long been read as a self-portrait, and Da Corte, in the audio guide, reads it that way too, a man in a panic about the machine that makes his pictures. Lichtenstein told the critic John Coplans that he wanted a painting to look as if it had been programmed. The programmer, in the picture read as his self-portrait, is a cartoon villain cornered on exactly that point.

Set the three men side by side and a pattern appears. The hero, Brad, has no face. The pilot has a helmet. The artist, in the picture read as his self-portrait, is a pair of eyes with no mouth, speaking in a balloon. Few critics at the time seem to have asked what he was doing with the men, because few were looking at them. They were the furniture the women cried in front of. That is the review’s headline made concrete, and it is worth noticing: the men were always the joke, and the joke was always on the costume.

III The Hand and the Brush

In August 1949 Life had asked, in an article on Jackson Pollock, whether he was the greatest living painter in the United States. In January 1964 the same magazine asked whether Lichtenstein was the worst. The two questions are a matched pair, and the pairing is an old one. Less often noticed is that Lichtenstein answered the first question himself. In 1965 he began painting brushstrokes: single, enormous, cartooned swipes of yellow or red, outlined in black, dripping cartoon drips, laid over a field of Benday dots. He showed them at Castelli’s that November. The Whitney owns one of the best of them, Little Big Painting, and it is in the show.

What it is doing is making a cartoon of the most heroic gesture in American art. Harold Rosenberg had written in 1952 that for the new painters the canvas was “an arena in which to act,” and the sentence had become a creed: the stroke was the man, the man was the act, and the act was proof of something that the photographs of Pollock, crouched over the canvas like a man over an engine, were taken to confirm. Pollock had been dead nine years by 1965. De Kooning was alive and painting. Into that room Lichtenstein carried a brushstroke with no brushstrokes in it, the drips outlined and filled in, the dots behind them pushed through a perforated screen. It is a man’s mark with the man taken out.

The source makes it better. The first Brushstrokes came from a panel in a Charlton horror comic, Strange Suspense Stories number 72, dated October 1964, a story called “The Painting” about an artist named Jake whose canvas seems to take on a life of its own. The panel shows a hand gripping a paintbrush, and Lichtenstein said he liked the cartoonist’s shorthand for the hand and the paint. So the emblem of the action painter’s authentic self was lifted from a twelve-cent story about a painter and a picture with a will of its own, drawn to order by an artist usually identified as Dick Giordano. Years later Lichtenstein told interviewers the real source was Frans Hals. That sounds like a joke too, and a good one, because by then the brushstrokes were in museums and nobody was going to check.

He never let the gesture go. Through the eighties and nineties the brushstroke became sculpture, made in metal and painted, standing in plazas and lobbies, and the show has one of these, Coups de pinceau, from 1988, fabricated in 2011, after his death. The arc is the essay’s argument in a single motif. The manly act becomes a cartoon, the cartoon becomes a logo, the logo becomes a monument, and at every stage the hand that made it is nowhere to be seen. If you want to know what the brushstrokes make of the American painter as hero, you do not need Als or a wall text. You need to stand in front of a brushstroke in painted metal and ask who, exactly, is supposed to have made the stroke.

A gold flight-jacket sleeve ending in an empty outlined hand that holds a long paintbrush, sweeping one huge crimson brushstroke with cartoon drips across a field of printer’s dots.
Nobody’s stroke, made for this essay.

IV In Quotation Marks

The review’s word is campy, and 1964, the year of the Life headline and of the redhead on the telephone, is also the year Susan Sontag gave camp its definition. “Notes on ‘Camp’” ran in Partisan Review that fall: fifty-eight numbered notes, dedicated to Oscar Wilde, on a sensibility that loves artifice, exaggeration and the thing that is slightly off. Her tenth note, on quotation marks, is the one that matters here: “not a lamp, but a ‘lamp’; not a woman, but a ‘woman.’” Among her examples of the sensibility she listed the old Flash Gordon comics. She had Pop art in front of her that season, and in her fifty-sixth note she set it beside camp and found it related but different: cooler and more aloof. The quotation marks, though, were already on the wall at Castelli’s. That is what the Benday dots are. They are the printer’s device that tells you a picture of a woman is a picture of a “woman,” and the dots cover the men as well.

Als has come back to the museum of Black Male thirty-two years later to review a painter who put the hero in quotation marks. Whether Lichtenstein meant it as critique is a separate question. The performance is on the wall. What it performs is the question.

So look at the redhead. Ohhh…Alright…, 1964, about three feet square, taken from a panel in the DC romance comic Secret Hearts: a woman with red hair and blue eyes holds a telephone to her ear and says, in a balloon, the two words of the title. Whoever she is talking to is not in the picture. In Drowning Girl, from the year before, the woman going under the wave would rather sink than call Brad. In Masterpiece Brad has his back to us. In a canvas of 1963 a tearful blonde tells Brad she knows how he must feel. Brad is faceless or unseen in all three. “‘Brad’ sounded like a hero to me,” Lichtenstein once said, and so every hero was to be called Brad; the idea, he added, had to do with cliché. The whole series of crying, drowning, telephoning women is a series of portraits of the hero’s absence. What most viewers saw was women in distress. The women are in distress about a man made of four letters and a telephone line.

There is a coda to the redhead that no novelist would dare. On November 10, 2010, at Christie’s in New York, Ohhh…Alright… was sold for $42,642,500, then the most ever paid for a Lichtenstein at auction, to an anonymous bidder who was not in the room. The bidder was on the telephone. A picture of a woman saying all right to a caller she cannot see went to a bidder nobody could see. If camp is the love of the thing that is slightly off, the sale was the campiest event in the painting’s life, and it took place forty-six years after the brush was put down.

V Like New

The title comes from a painting of 1962 in two panels: a screen with a hole in it and, beside it, the repair, after an advertisement for screen repair. The mend is a field of Benday dots. The curators’ stated aim was to slow the viewer down: Da Corte has said he wanted people to look at Lichtenstein more slowly, and Onli that recognizing a picture is not the same as understanding it. So the show reunites the paintings of his first Castelli show, of February 1962, and in its galleries on duplication it hangs copies made of his pictures by Elaine Sturtevant and Richard Pettibone beside his originals. Lichtenstein is said to have supplied stencils for Sturtevant’s copy and to have signed a Pettibone. Across the street, on a building facade, a vinyl print of his Hot Dog of 1963 carries Da Corte’s ketchup. A show about a man who hid the hand that made the pictures is full of other hands. Set side by side, the absences make a single figure: the hero has no face, the painter hid his hand, and the men who drew the hero seldom saw their names in print.

Now give the other side its full weight, because it is strong. The first objection is Heath’s, and no answer has quieted it: the hero was drawn by a working man at a page rate, and the critique of the hero was sold by a man who did not pay him. David Barsalou’s “Deconstructing Lichtenstein” project has spent years matching canvas after canvas to its panel and its artist. The second objection is Lichtenstein’s own. He called the heroes fascists in one breath and formal devices in the next, and said the name Brad had to do with cliché. He named the critique and declined to stand on it, and a reading of the men as costume is laid over a man who did exactly that. Als’s review has a note of its own, about the happy white man of its first paragraph, and the essay leaves it where he put it.

The concession that hurts is this. If the men in the pictures are the costume, the men who drew the costume were real. Lichtenstein was put in pilot training for the war and never flew; Novick and Heath drew that war for a living, and Kirby drew the hero, for children, on deadline. A joke on the posture of the American man was also, whatever the painter intended, a joke that ran straight across their drawing boards, and Heath’s charge sits beside it unanswered: that the painter grew rich on pictures the comics men had been paid for by the page. The essay cannot get around that. Da Corte’s hand is in the room, and the viewer can decide whether a re-created billboard is a tribute, a reparation or another duplication.

What remains is the man himself, the one figure the show cannot put in quotation marks: the draftee who never flew, the teacher who was thirty-eight when his first Castelli show opened, the husband whose marriage came apart while he painted women on telephones, and then, for thirty years, a famous artist who could name the politics of his pictures and take them back in the same breath. In his Pop years he painted the villain’s eyes long read as his self-portrait, and in 1978 a shirt with a mirror where the head should be. The review is right that the wit is the best of him. The curious reader leaves the fifth floor with a question the wit keeps turning aside, and it is not about Brad.

If the man in the picture was a costume, who was wearing it?

⁂

Sources: Hilton Als, “Roy Lichtenstein’s Witty Critiques of Masculinity,” The New Yorker, November 9, 2026, online November 2. The Whitney Museum of American Art’s pages for Roy Lichtenstein: Like New, including its gallery texts on the Castelli Gallery, The Duplication Machine and the New York World’s Fair Mural, its audio guide, and its page for Alex Da Corte’s Hot Dog with Ketchup; Meg Onli and Alex Da Corte in conversation with Hypebeast, October 2026; Introspective on the Super Sunset Billboard; Sotheby’s, New York, 2018, on Like New. On the comics: Tate Etc., Spring 2013, on Whaam!, and The Art Newspaper, February 2013, on its purchase; Russ Heath as quoted by Smithsonian, and the New York Times obituary of Heath, August 2018, as reprinted by WRAL; Bart Beaty, Comics Versus Art (2012), and CBR on Irv Novick’s 1998 account, and Lambiek Comiclopedia on Novick’s Cynthia; David Barsalou’s “Deconstructing Lichtenstein”; Diane Waldman, Roy Lichtenstein (Guggenheim Museum, 1993), and the Art Institute of Chicago on the Brushstrokes source; and Roy Lichtenstein: A Catalogue Raisonné, on Image Duplicator and I Know How You Must Feel, Brad…. Lichtenstein on the comic-book heroes as quoted in James Naremore and Patrick Brantlinger, eds., Modernity and Mass Culture (1991), p. 208. Life, January 31, 1964, as given by the Castelli Gallery; Christie’s on Ohhh…Alright…, sold November 10, 2010; Bloomberg on the 2017 sale of Masterpiece. The Whitney library’s record for Thelma Golden’s Black Male catalogue (1994). John Coplans, ed., Roy Lichtenstein (1972); Harold Rosenberg, “The American Action Painters,” ARTnews, December 1952; Susan Sontag, “Notes on ‘Camp,’” Partisan Review, Fall 1964, collected in Against Interpretation (1966). Drafted with Claude Opus 5.5; literary and copy editing by Claude Sonnet 5.5; cold read by Claude Fable 5.1. Images generated with Gemini Argon.

WHO IS LEFT TO BE WRONG

On a sixty-seven-year-old complaint, a pledge borrowed from a cartoon rabbit, and the rules that stop where a critic’s career begins

Reviewers were never as fierce as we remember. What has gone missing is not cruelty but cover: somewhere to stand while saying, in print and under one’s own name, that a book has failed.

In October 1959, Elizabeth Hardwick looked at the American book pages and found the old fear misplaced. Readers still pictured the critic as a fickle demon, and remembered Keats turning his face to the wall after a bad notice. Hardwick thought a Keats of her own day would die another way. He would choke, she wrote, on what Emerson called a “mush of concession.”

Her complaint was not that reviewers were cruel. It was that they were kind to everything. “Sweet, bland commendations fall everywhere upon the scene,” and a new book “is born into a puddle of treacle.” That was sixty-seven years ago. The complaint has been made again since, by people who meant it, and the condition it describes has outlasted every one of them. So the useful question is not why reviewers are kind. Most always were. It is a narrower one, and harder: who is left to be wrong?

I

The Treacle Baseline

Hardwick brought a number with her. A study at Wayne University had sorted the reviews summarised in Book Review Digest for 1956, and by her report 51 per cent were favourable, 44.8 per cent non-committal, and 4.7 per cent unfavourable. No second source for the study has surfaced, so the figures rest on her account. Even so, they are worth sitting with, because of the decade they describe.

The 1950s are the decade usually remembered as the great age of American criticism, the age of the quarterlies and of Edmund Wilson. In it, by this count, fewer than one review in twenty said that a book had failed. Nearly half declined to say anything at all. Severity was never the ordinary condition of reviewing. It was a fringe.

What the fringe had was somewhere to stand. The 4.7 per cent were published by someone: a staff position, a quarterly, an editor who would print the unfavourable notice and take the letters. That is an inference from the shape of the period rather than a finding, but it locates the loss. What matters is what happened to the few who were willing to be wrong in print, and to the places that let them stand.

Part of the answer is that the two sides of the old quarrel became one person. The mid-century suspicion was that critics and novelists were rivals, perhaps rivals inside a single mind. In September 2026, in a conversation published by Cultured, the critic and novelist Chris Kraus put the present plainly: “I don’t know anyone who writes criticism who doesn’t write fiction.” The war between them did not end in a victory. The two armies merged, and every critic now has a book of her own coming out.

II

The Anatomy of a Claim

It helps to be exact about what has gone missing, because it is not hostility. Hostility is plentiful. What is scarce is a claim of a particular kind: one grounded closely enough in the work that a reader can go back to it and say, no, you misread this. Call it a falsifiable claim, in the loose sense criticism allows. Literary judgments are not experiments, but some can be shown wrong by the text and some cannot. Enthusiasm cannot. A reviewer who says she was moved has told the truth about herself, and nothing that can be checked about the book.

In the spring of 1976, in the first issue of a journal called October, Rosalind Krauss made a claim of the other kind. Her subject was the new art of video, and her thesis took six words: “The medium of video is narcissism.” The camera and the monitor, she argued, closed a loop between the performer and her own image, so that the work turned the self back on itself.

That would have been a provocation. What made it criticism was the next move. Within the same fifteen pages, Krauss named the work that could sink her claim. She identified three kinds of video that cut against the thesis, and she took them one at a time: Richard Serra and Nancy Holt’s Boomerang, in which Holt hears her own words come back to her a beat late; Joan Jonas’s Vertical Roll, in which the picture is broken by a rolling bar; and Peter Campus’s installations, which throw the viewer back against a wall. She did not explain them away. She asked what each one did to her argument and gave her answer. A reader with the tapes could test every step.

That is the whole content of the word “falsifiable.” The claimant hands over the evidence that could prove her wrong, along with the claim.

The contrast with the present is not a matter of courage or talent. It is a matter of form. Krauss had fifteen pages in a quarterly and a readership that expected to argue back. A newspaper review is a fraction of that length, written to a deadline measured in days. Ben Eastham, who began reviewing exhibitions for the Guardian this year, says he sees the show in the morning and has to file in the afternoon. A claim that names its own counter-examples takes room and time, and the form that once supplied them has shrunk.

Kraus, who began the same conversation by saying every critic now writes fiction, went on to say that criticism by people who are themselves artists and writers has become “a lot softer and more diffuse for better and for worse.” The last four words matter. She is not lamenting. She is recording a trade, and she does not pretend that only one side of it was lost. She is also her own best counter-example: a novelist who still makes claims that can be argued with. Which suggests that the problem is not the writer who does both. It is the economy she does both in.

III

The Two Economies

Hardwick saw money coming and turned it away. The popular explanation in 1959 was that book sections went soft because publishers bought their advertising. Hardwick considered it and decided the decline was “not always to be laid at the door of commerce.” The advertising theory, she wrote, “has, naturally, had an exaggerated acceptance.” Her culprit was editing. The trouble with the Sunday sections was the absence of editors who cared about the literary tone, and she said so at length, naming names. She never mentions what a reviewer was paid.

What she rejected was a theory of influence: that publishers lean on editors, and editors lean on reviewers, and reviews come out soft. She does not say why money seemed beside the point. The likely reason, which is an inference and not hers, is that her reviewers were salaried journalists and academics, for whom a review was an occasion rather than a living. If so, the explanation she dismissed is still the wrong one, and the economy that matters now is one she had no occasion to see.

Nobody leans on anyone in it. Of the twelve leading review outlets whose guidelines were checked on 2 October 2026, none publishes a rate for reviews, and only two say they pay contributors at all. Reviewing fiction is no longer, for most who do it, a job. It is something a working writer does alongside her own books, her teaching, her applications. A novelist who reviews novels will, over a career, be reviewed by the people she reviews. She may sit beside them on juries, need their names on a fellowship application, hope for a sentence from them on the back of her next book. None of this requires a threat. Nobody asks her to be kind. The economy gives no instructions. It makes some sentences more expensive to write than others.

The people inside it have described it themselves. Elvia Wilk, in the same Cultured conversation, said that reviewing for money had come to feel like “service-oriented writing,” and that she turned to fiction because she needed something private. Eastham spoke of “a certain responsibility” to the artist that shapes what a critic can say. Neither described fear, and neither needed to. They were describing a condition, not a threat.

The condition had its open argument in 2012. That August, Jacob Silverman published an essay in Slate against what its subtitle called “the epidemic of niceness in online book culture,” arguing that social media rewarded agreement: “It’s easier to enthuse than discuss.” Within days Roxane Gay answered him in Salon, and others defended enthusiasm as a form of generosity. They were not wrong that generosity is worth something. But the quarrel ended the way such quarrels do, with each side more certain, and nothing written down anywhere about who should do the judging.

The next year, the argument acquired its only policy. In November 2013 BuzzFeed hired Isaac Fitzgerald to start a books section, and in an interview with Poynter he said it would not run negative reviews. “Why waste breath talking smack about something?” He called his principle the Bambi Rule, though the line he quoted belongs to Thumper: if you can’t say something nice, don’t say nothing at all. A week later, in the Columbia Journalism Review, Ann Friedman defended him, on the grounds that what BuzzFeed was building was a community of readers, not a review section in the old sense.

The defence conceded more than the attack had. If a books section that will not judge is doing something other than reviewing, then the work of judgment has not been abolished. It has simply been left unclaimed. That pledge is thirteen years old, and the section that made it has gone quiet: its staffed books desk lapsed between 2021 and the closure of BuzzFeed News in 2023, though a books page still runs quizzes and lists. It remains the only public statement of the kind on record. Nobody has needed to make another.

IV

The Rival Reading

There is a strong case that the fringe deserved to dwindle, and it should be put at full strength. The great quarrels of the old order are remembered less for their arguments than for their tempers.

In February 1962, F.R. Leavis gave the Richmond Lecture at Downing College, Cambridge, on C.P. Snow, the novelist and scientist whose lecture on the “two cultures” had made him famous. Leavis said that as a novelist Snow “doesn’t begin to exist,” and found in his thought an “utter lack of intellectual distinction.” The lecture was in the Spectator within ten days. It is remembered as a performance of contempt, and the contempt has outlived whatever case it contained.

The prize for severity, when someone finally offered one, was a joke. From 2012 to 2014 the website The Omnivore gave a Hatchet Job of the Year award for the most savage and witty review of the year. The prize was a year’s supply of potted shrimp. After three years it stopped. Severity had become a comic genre, and comic genres tire.

Against all this, appreciation has its own serious tradition. Susan Sontag ended “Against Interpretation” with a sentence that a generation took as a programme: “In place of a hermeneutics we need an erotics of art.” And when Eastham speaks of the critic as a collaborator, he is quoting John Berger, accurately. In “Critic’s Credo,” in 1955, Berger distinguished studio criticism, which he likened to a form of teaching, from public criticism, written for the general reader, whose task was to connect works of art with ordinary life. Collaboration is a real calling, and the sneer was never its only alternative.

But Berger is worth following a little further. In November 1972, at the Café Royal in London, he accepted the Booker Prize for his novel G. and used the speech to point out that the prize’s sponsor, Booker McConnell, had held trading interests in the Caribbean for more than a century. He gave half the money to the Black Panther movement in Britain and kept the rest for his book on migrant workers. “The half I give away will change the half I keep.” The man who wrote the credo about responsibility to artists also stood up at a dinner held in his honour and told his hosts, in their own room, exactly what he thought of them. The two were never incompatible.

Which is the distinction the old quarrels obscure. An opponent is not an enemy. In 1965 Edmund Wilson reviewed his friend Vladimir Nabokov’s translation of Eugene Onegin in the New York Review of Books, harshly. Nabokov replied in the same pages, point by numbered point. Wilson’s answer, printed beneath, began: “I must acknowledge two errors.” Others joined, and the exchange ran from July of that year into the following January. It is often said to have ended their friendship. What it did not end was the argument: both men stayed in the room, under their own names, for six months, and readers could watch them be right and wrong in turn. That is the thing Leavis’s lecture and the potted shrimp both lack, and the thing Berger at the Café Royal had. Not hostility, which is cheap, but a signed position, held in public, by someone who expects to be answered and stays to hear the answer.

V

The Ledger

If what has gone missing is cover for the signed claim, the place to look for it is in what the outlets themselves say. On 2 October 2026 the published guidelines of twelve leading review outlets in English were captured and read: the New York Review of Books, the London Review of Books, the Times Literary Supplement, Bookforum, The Point, The Baffler, n+1, The Nation, Harper’s, The New Yorker, the New York Times Book Review, and the Guardian’s books pages.

Three publish no guidance for reviewers at all. Seven publish guidance that says nothing about judgment, favourable or otherwise. Two say something. The Point tells contributors it wants critical argument rather than straight reviews, which is a statement about the form of judgment, not about its direction. And the New York Times Book Review’s then editor, describing its practice in 2016, said that books the editors liked could still receive negative notices, and that a reviewer is disqualified who knows the author, shares an agent, or blurbed an earlier book. The Guardian’s Editorial Code, revised in March 2026, bars writing about a relative, a partner or a close friend.

So the claim that survives is narrow, and anyone can check it by opening those pages. No outlet among the twelve publishes a policy on negative reviewing. The only rules that touch the question are conflict-of-interest rules, and they stop at friendship and at favours already done.

In a library flooded with amber syrup, a brass scale stands on a stone plinth under a shaft of light. A sealed, unopened envelope outweighs a handwritten page with one line struck through in red, and its pan sinks toward the syrup.
The weight of a favour not yet done, made for this essay.

That is not negligence. Conflict rules exist to catch known relationships, and they do that job well. A reviewer who has blurbed the author is visibly compromised, and the rule removes her. What the rule cannot reach is the reviewer who has not yet been blurbed and would like to be, who has not yet sat on the author’s jury and might. Nobody has a relationship with a future favour. It appears on no disclosure form, because it has not happened, and it may never happen. It only has to be possible. The peer economy begins exactly where the conflict rules end, and no code could follow it there, because what lives there is not a conflict. It is a career.

None of this measures how common negative reviews are now. Hardwick’s 4.7 per cent described 1956, by her report, and it is not a measure of anything since.

A magazine written by working writers sits inside the same economy, and this one is no exception. Its essays have turned to history, the classics and ideas, and it has not published a signed review of a new novel, favourable or otherwise. Its contributors write within the same network as everyone else’s. The finding about twelve outlets can be checked, and if necessary corrected, by anyone who opens their pages.

The last time this complaint was made with real force, it had a sequel. In the winter of 1962 to 1963 a printers’ strike shut the New York newspapers, and with them their Sunday book sections. Hardwick, Robert Lowell, Barbara and Jason Epstein and Robert Silvers, the editor who had commissioned her essay at Harper’s, used the silence to start the New York Review of Books. The answer to “The Decline of Book Reviewing” was not a better argument. It was a place to stand.

Sixty-three years later, the New York Review is one of the twelve, and one of the three that publish no guidance for reviewers at all. That is not a charge against it. Its pages are where Wilson and Nabokov argued for six months, under editors who printed both. The fact is the plainest evidence of something simpler. The shelter was its editors, and what they would print was never a rule anyone wrote down.

Whether that answer can be given again is an open question. It may be that the fringe needs only a new shelter, and that someone will build it. It may be that the existing shelters could decide to be one, and say so in the one page no outlet has yet written. Or it may be that the gentleness Hardwick deplored has found a better defence than she imagined, in a culture of writers who would rather sustain one another than judge, and who have weighed what that costs. The guidelines pages cannot say which.

⁂

Written in full collaboration with the machine, and the ledger requires the names be exact: drafted and edited with Claude Fable 5.1 and Claude Opus 5.5; copy editing by Gemini. No quotation in this essay was recalled; each was checked against a text of its source, the original or a reproduction of it, and any text reached secondhand was confirmed in two reproductions or paraphrased.

Elizabeth Hardwick is quoted from “The Decline of Book Reviewing,” Harper’s Magazine, October 1959, in the magazine’s online archive; Emerson’s phrase is quoted as she quotes it, and the figures from the Wayne University study of Book Review Digest for 1956 are given as she reports them, since no second source for the study has been found. Rosalind Krauss is quoted from “Video: The Aesthetics of Narcissism,” October 1 (Spring 1976), pp. 50–64. F.R. Leavis is quoted from the Richmond Lecture as printed in the Spectator, 9 March 1962, in reproduction. Susan Sontag’s closing sentence is from “Against Interpretation” (1964), in reproduction. John Berger’s “Critic’s Credo” (Art News and Review, 14 May 1955) is paraphrased; his Booker Prize speech of 23 November 1972 is quoted from the text reproduced by Verso and the Booker Prizes. Edmund Wilson’s reply to Vladimir Nabokov is from the New York Review of Books archive, 26 August 1965. Chris Kraus, Elvia Wilk and Ben Eastham are quoted from “Three Acclaimed Critics Reveal What Lured Them Into the World of Fiction,” Cultured, 28 September 2026. Jacob Silverman is quoted from Slate, August 2012, and Isaac Fitzgerald from his interview with Poynter, 7 November 2013.

The published guidelines of twelve outlets were captured on 2 October 2026 and classified as no guidance found, guidance silent on judgment, or guidance addressing it. A count of signed negative reviews of new novels across the same outlets, for the twelve months to 30 September 2026, was designed and signed off before counting began, piloted on one issue, costed at 200 to 400 hours with subscriptions to every outlet, and abandoned on grounds of method; no figure from the pilot is used. A signed negative review of a praised contemporary novel would be a different piece, with its own apparatus, and a full count by readers with access to every outlet would be a companion project. The verification ledger, with every outlet’s URL and classification and the source for each quotation, is in the source of this page, for anyone who wants to check.

The header and interior images were generated with Gemini for this essay; they illustrate its argument and depict no real place or event.

On the collaboration → “The Third Thing”