Tag Archives: NASA

OTHER THAN LIFE ITSELF

In 1848 a man sorted crystals into left and right by eye. In 2003 a sealed flask, given one extra molecule in two million, made almost nothing but one hand. The committee said that, other than life itself, no one had done that before.

Henri Kagan, 95, and Kenso Soai, 76, won this year’s chemistry prize for showing how a slight preference for one mirror image can grow. Life did something like it to its amino acids and sugars. Where its first preference came from is still open, and so is whether it was a preference at all.

Buy a sprig of spearmint and a jar of caraway seed, and smell one and then the other. The two scents come from one molecule and its mirror image: the same atoms, joined in the same order. Your nose can tell them apart.

Hold a corkscrew up to a mirror and the one in the glass spirals the other way. Either would open a bottle, because a cork has no preference. A nut threaded for one would refuse the other. Your nose is threaded, and so is the rest of you. Life builds its proteins from one mirror form of amino acid and its genes from one form of sugar. No one knows why.

Louis Pasteur, the chemist who first pulled a substance apart into its two mirror forms, thought in 1860 that this might be the one line that could be drawn between the chemistry of the living and the dead. Whatever a chemist made from simple ingredients came out as an even mixture of the two forms. Only living things, and what came from them, made one form alone.

On the morning of October 7, in Stockholm, the Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences announced that this year’s chemistry prize would go to two men who had spent their working lives near that line. Henri Kagan, in France, had shown in 1986 that a flawed catalyst could do better than anyone expected. Kenso Soai, in Japan, had built a flask in which one form makes more of itself until the other has all but gone. Of what Soai’s flask had done, the Academy wrote: “Other than life itself, no one had previously achieved this feat.”

It is a generous sentence, and a strange one. It sets a flask of glass beside the whole of biology, at the same task. Follow how the flask got there, and the compliment begins to run the other way.

A still life on a worn oak table: green grapes and an autumn vine leaf on a pewter plate; a sealed round glass flask of clear liquid that shows the grapes upside down; a black meteorite fragment on a nest of hay. A cork, a sprig of mint and caraway seeds lie in front.
In French a still life is a nature morte, dead nature. Pasteur’s line once ran between the grapes and the glass. Image made for this essay.

I

In the Morning

Pull the cork from a bottle of white wine that has spent the night in the refrigerator, and you may find a crust of small glassy crystals on its underside. Winemakers call them wine diamonds. They are harmless, a salt of tartaric acid, the sharp acid of grapes. Every one of them is built from the same mirror form of that acid, because the grape makes only one.

In the early nineteenth century tartaric acid was an industry. At the Kestner works in Thann, in Alsace, it was boiled out of the crust that wine leaves inside its casks and sold to the region’s cloth printers. In the early 1820s, mostly in winter, stray crystals turned up in the vats. They had the same makeup as tartaric acid, atom for atom, but they did not behave like it. The new substance was named for its source, acide racémique, from the Latin for a bunch of grapes. The works never made it again. The name stayed: a chemist still calls any even mixture of two mirror forms racemic, which means, if you trace it back, “of grapes.”

The difference showed in light. Pass light through certain crystals and it comes out vibrating in a single plane, like a rope shaken only up and down. Send that light through a solution of the grape’s tartaric acid and the plane turns a little to the right. Jean-Baptiste Biot, a physicist in Paris, had spent much of his life measuring such turns. Send it through the acid from Thann and it came out unturned. The same atoms, and no turn. Nobody could say why.

In 1848 Louis Pasteur was a young chemist at the École Normale in Paris, more interested in the shapes of crystals than in wine. A leading German crystal chemist had reported that a salt of the grape’s acid and the same salt of the Thann acid were alike in every way he could find, except for what they did to light. Pasteur made the Thann salt himself and looked at its crystals more closely than anyone had. On each one were small extra faces. On some crystals they leaned to the right, on others to the left, so that each crystal was the mirror image of another. He sorted them into two piles by eye. Dissolved, one pile turned light to the right, exactly as the grape’s acid did. The other turned it to the left, by the same amount. Mixed in equal weights, the two turned it not at all. The acid from Thann was the grape’s acid and its mirror twin, in equal shares.

Temperature mattered. This salt separates into left and right crystals only when it is cool; a few degrees warmer, it crystallizes as a single mixed kind, with nothing to sort. When Pasteur wrote out the method in 1850 for anyone who wanted to repeat it, it read like a recipe. Let the solution stand for a few days, until some of the crystals are several centimeters long. Take them out in the morning, because the day’s rising warmth dissolves them a little and erases the small faces. Pour off the liquid, wipe each crystal with crumpled blotting paper, and sort them one by one by the lean of their faces.

Biot did not take the result on trust. He had Pasteur make the salt again from Biot’s own acid, soda and ammonia, and leave it to crystallize in Biot’s own rooms at the Collège de France. Pasteur sorted the crop in front of him and said which pile would turn the light which way. Biot made the solutions himself, and looked first at the one that should turn it to the left: a form of the acid that, until Pasteur’s sorting, no one had ever held in a bottle. He saw it turn. Telling the story in 1860, Pasteur remembered the old man taking him by the arm: “My dear child, I have loved science so much throughout my life that this makes my heart throb.”

In the years that followed, Pasteur found two more ways to pull the forms apart. He mixed the Thann acid with an alkaloid from the bark of the cinchona tree, the tree that gives quinine. The tree’s molecule has a form of its own, so it got on differently with the two acids, and one came out of solution before the other. Then he let a common mold loose in a solution of the even mixture. The mold ate one form and left the other alone, and the liquid, which had done nothing to light when he began, slowly began to turn it. Each way of sorting needed something that could already tell left from right: a man’s eye, a tree’s alkaloid, a mold’s appetite.

He also tried to make one form from nothing. He grew crystals beside powerful magnets, and set up mirrors to make the sun appear to cross the sky backwards over growing plants. The magnets failed, and so did the mirrors.

By 1860, lecturing to the chemists of Paris, he set out what it all came to. That living things made one form alone established, in his words, “perhaps the only well-marked line of demarcation that can at present be drawn between the chemistry of dead matter and the chemistry of living matter.”

II

Borrowed Hands

Even inside a living body, a form does not always hold. Leave a molecule long enough, and warm enough, and it drifts toward an even mixture of its two forms. One amino acid in the dentin of your teeth drifts this way, year after year, so steadily that a tooth can be used to estimate its owner’s age. Thalidomide, the sedative that in the late 1950s and early 1960s harmed children before they were born, was sold as an even mixture of its two forms, and in the blood either form turns into the other within hours. One form has to be held against that drift. Getting it in the first place is harder.

For most of a century after Pasteur, a chemist could make one form only by starting from something that already had one. In 1904 a German chemist managed a slight excess of one form with brucine, an alkaloid from the seeds of the strychnine tree. Then, from the 1970s, came pure one-handed catalysts: molecules that help a reaction along and come out unchanged, ready to help again, so that each can stamp its form on a great many molecules of product. That work was honored with the chemistry prize in 2001. One of those catalysts, built on the grape’s tartrate, is the one that turns up in Kagan’s flask.

In 1986 every careful chemist wanted a purer catalyst. At Orsay, a university town south of Paris, Kagan made his worse on purpose, to test an idea he had first considered, he later wrote, in the late 1960s. He mixed the grape’s tartrate with a measured share of its mirror twin until it was only partly one-handed, and ran the reaction to see what came out. The rule chemists used was a straight line, drawn and seldom tested: a catalyst only partly one form would make a product only partly one form, in proportion, because each mirror-twin catalyst molecule would make mirror-twin product. By that line a flawed catalyst could only make a product flawed in the same proportion. It came out purer than the line allowed.

Kagan’s explanation is a picture anyone can hold. His catalyst works in pairs. Two of the same form make a pair that works. A right paired with a left, which Kagan called a “marriage,” makes a pair that barely works, and it sits out. The minority form, always the scarcer partner, ends up mostly married and idle, so the pairs still at work are mostly of the majority’s form. The worse catalyst behaves like a better one.

Pasteur had shown a room full of chemists the same kind of attraction. At the end of his first lecture in 1860 he poured together strong solutions of the grape’s acid and its mirror twin. The mixture grew warm, the liquid set solid, and the room applauded. In that crystal, each form takes more readily to its twin than to its own kind.

Drawn as a graph, with the catalyst’s purity along the bottom and the product’s up the side, Kagan’s results bowed above the old straight line, and the bend became an instrument. The shape of the curve shows whether a catalyst’s molecules work alone or in company, which no microscope can show, and chemists still draw it to look inside reactions they cannot watch. Later, a drug company’s chemists put the bend to work. They made a reagent from pinene, out of pine resin, that was far from pure, and got back a product almost entirely of one form.

Every hand in this part of the story came from something alive: the seeds of one tree, the resin of another, the grape. The product can beat the line, but the maker’s hand still came from the grape.

III

The Flask That Chose

In 1953, two flasks stood for the beginning of life.

One was real. In a laboratory in Chicago, a graduate student sealed water and the gases then thought to make up the early Earth’s air inside a loop of glass, and sent sparks through it for a week to stand in for lightning. By the end of the first day the water was pink; by the end of the week it was a deep, murky red. In it were amino acids, the building blocks of proteins, made from nothing but gas, water and electricity. They came in both forms, evenly. Whatever gave life one form, lightning alone had not.

The other existed only on paper. In Bristol that year F. C. Frank, a physicist who spent most of his career on how crystals grow and where they go wrong, published a short note in a biochemistry journal. He imagined a molecule that does three jobs: it makes more of itself; it makes more in its own form; and it gets in its mirror twin’s way. Start such a mixture perfectly even, let chance tip it the slightest bit, and it would run on by itself until only one form was left. He closed with one careful sentence: “A laboratory demonstration may not be impossible.” His flask stayed on paper until 1995.

Crystals got there first. Late in the 1980s, chemists in North Carolina were growing crystals of sodium chlorate, a salt whose molecules have no mirror form at all, though its crystals do: each one packs its atoms with a twist one way or the other. Left alone, a flask of it grows left and right crystals in roughly equal numbers. Stirred, it grew crystals nearly all of one kind, and which kind changed from flask to flask. By one account the stirring began on a whim, after one of them watched a crystal sink to the bottom of the flask. When they sent the result to a journal, one of its referees repeated it. The usual explanation is that the stirring broke the first crystal to form into fragments, and each fragment seeded new crystals in its own form. It was a world of one hand, made by nothing but motion and chance. But the hand lived in the stack, not the molecule. Dissolve the crystals and it is gone. That is why the Academy’s phrase still stands. It is about molecules.

Kenso Soai has spent most of his working life at the Tokyo University of Science. His chemistry joins a zinc compound to a small ring-shaped molecule to make an alcohol, and the zinc compound catches fire in air, so the work runs dry and sealed. In 1990 Soai found an alcohol that made more of itself in its own form: a little of one form in the flask helped turn out more of the same. But each batch came out less one-handed than the catalyst that made it. Frank had said what was missing. A molecule that only makes more of itself can at best keep the ratio it starts with, and in practice it slips; it must also get in its mirror twin’s way.

Five years later Soai found a molecule that did all three of Frank’s jobs. Take a little of what one flask made and use it to start the next, and each new batch came out more one-handed than the catalyst that made it, round after round. What Soai had built was an amplifier for left and right.

How his molecule got in its mirror twin’s way took longer to see. Chemists who measured the heat the reaction gives off as it runs found it behaving as though its catalyst worked in pairs. Frank’s last condition, the one Soai’s first molecule lacked, turned out to be Kagan’s marriage. In Soai’s flask too, a right paired with a left sits out. Not every account of the reaction agrees, but more than one does, and in those the two halves of this year’s prize meet in a single flask.

In 2003 his group gave the amplifier its hardest test. They mixed a trace of the one-handed alcohol into an even mixture until the excess was one molecule in two million. By the third run the flask was making almost nothing but one form.

Then they gave it nothing one-handed at all. Thirty-seven flasks were started with none of the alcohol in either form, sealed and run. Every one came out leaning, some a little and some heavily: eighteen one way, nineteen the other. A group in Texas had found the same the year before.

Something tipped each flask. It could be a stray trace of anything one-handed, a speck of dust from something once alive. It could, it seems, be nothing more than which few molecules happened to form first.

None of them chose.

IV

A Cause or an Accident

Kagan’s bend is useful. Soai’s reaction is good for nothing but itself: it makes one obscure alcohol nobody needs. A method is worth what it makes. A proof is worth what it rules out, and Soai’s flasks ruled out the oldest suspicion in this story, that only life could give molecules one hand from none. In the seeded flask, a hand diluted almost to nothing grew back. In the unseeded ones, a hand appeared where none had been put in.

It is not, the committee is careful to add, how life did it. Life’s chemistry runs in water, and water ruins this one.

In 1957 physicists found, to the disbelief of some of the best of them, that one force in nature can tell left from right: the weak force, which governs some kinds of radioactive decay. By some calculations it favors the form life’s amino acids take, by a margin far smaller than the chance excess of a few molecules that can tip a flask on its own.

Soai’s flask turned out to be finer than any instrument that measures the turning of light. His group tipped it with quartz, whose crystals come in left and right. They tipped it with crystals of the salt that sorts itself when stirred, and with something lit by light twisted one way. They tipped it with a molecule whose two sides differed by one extra neutron in a single carbon atom, and the alcohol followed the neutron. That turned “could this tip anything?” into an experiment. Which thing tipped life, it cannot say.

An instrument that fine cannot be shielded. Had something in the room been leaning on all thirty-seven flasks, they would have leaned together. They hadn’t. Whatever tipped them favored neither side. An amplifier makes a cause indistinguishable from an accident. Soai ran thirty-seven flasks and could count. Life, as far as anyone knows, ran once.

V

Other Than Life Itself

The news of the prize found Soai out shopping. That evening, on the telephone, he spoke first of Pasteur, who had tried before him, and called his own part a small contribution to the problem.

The problem runs back through everything alive. In a living thing, every hand comes from a hand before it. The grape makes its acid with enzymes built from one-handed amino acids, which were made in turn by enzymes before them. Followed back, the chain has to start somewhere. Where did the grape get its own?

On a Sunday morning, September 28, 1969, a fireball crossed the sky over Victoria, in southeastern Australia, and broke apart above the small town of Murchison. Pieces fell across the paddocks, and one came through a roof and landed in hay. People who picked them up said they smelled of methylated spirits.

The stone is a fragment of an asteroid as old as the solar system. Two chemists in Arizona found in it amino acids that life doesn’t use, leaning toward the form life does use. That amino acids fall from space is familiar by now; these arrived leaning. Because life doesn’t use them, the lean can’t be contamination from the people who picked up the stones. These amino acids barely flip, unlike the one in your teeth, so the lean has lasted almost as long as the solar system has existed.

Murchison’s parent asteroid was not always dry. Early on, it was warm enough inside for ice to melt and seep through its rock. Later, chemists at NASA compared stones. Where water had once soaked through them, these amino acids leaned, Murchison’s by nearly a fifth. In stones water had barely touched, they didn’t lean at all.

So the stone is a witness from outside every laboratory. It carries a seed nobody can name, and an amplifier that seems to have worked in water, where Soai’s flask cannot. How a lean in these amino acids could pass to the ones life uses is still an open question.

The Academy set a flask beside the whole of life, as if the flask had risen to life’s level. It may be the other way round. What life did to its molecules may need nothing a flask cannot do: a tilt no one meant, made larger by molecules that make more of themselves, somewhere in water, once. Or it may need something not yet imagined. The stone does not say. It is what it was on the morning it fell: a stone that arrived leaning, for reasons nobody can yet explain.

⁂

This essay answers the Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences’ award of the Nobel Prize in Chemistry 2026 to Henri B. Kagan and Kenso Soai (October 7, 2026). It draws on the Academy’s press release, popular information and scientific background. The committee’s phrase is “previously achieved” in the press release and “ever achieved” in the popular information; the press release is followed. Kagan’s finding is from C. Puchot, O. Samuel, E. Duñach, S. Zhao, C. Agami and H. B. Kagan, Journal of the American Chemical Society 108 (1986). Soai’s first self-making alcohol is from K. Soai, S. Niwa and H. Hori, Journal of the Chemical Society, Chemical Communications (1990), and his amplifying one from K. Soai, T. Shibata, H. Morioka and K. Choji, Nature 378 (1995). The press release describes Soai’s 2003 success in one sentence that draws on two papers, the seeded experiment (Sato, Urabe, Ishiguro, Shibata and Soai, Angewandte Chemie, 2003) and the unseeded one (Soai and colleagues, Tetrahedron: Asymmetry, 2003); the figures here are from the scientific background and the papers.

Pasteur is quoted from his 1860 lectures to the Société chimique de Paris in the Alembic Club translation, including his own account of Biot’s verification. Gerald Geison and Howard Flack have tested his 1860 account of what led him to the discovery against his notebooks, and Joseph Gal has defended it; the essay relies on it only for Biot’s verification. His method for the separation is from his 1850 memoir, “Recherches sur les propriétés spécifiques des deux acides qui composent l’acide racémique,” Annales de chimie et de physique, 3rd series, 28. The blotting paper and the morning harvest are given as Hervé This quotes them in the Notes académiques de l’Académie d’agriculture de France (2021), from whom the account of the Kestner works is also drawn. The familiar picture of Pasteur sorting crystals under a microscope with tweezers comes from later biography, not his own accounts, and repeating his separation has not always succeeded.

Kagan’s word “marriage” is from his review in Oil & Gas Science and Technology (2007); his first consideration of the idea in the late 1960s is from his personal account in Synlett (2001), as cited by the committee. F. C. Frank is quoted from Biochimica et Biophysica Acta 11 (1953). The 1953 spark experiment follows Stanley Miller’s paper in Science (May 15, 1953). The stirred-salt result is from D. K. Kondepudi, R. J. Kaufman and N. Singh in Science (1990); the whim, the sinking crystal and the referee are from Charles Day’s account in Physics Today (April 2005); and the usual explanation is disputed (C. Viedma, Physical Review Letters, 2005). The disbelief of 1957 is Wolfgang Pauli’s among others, in his letter to Victor Weisskopf of January 17, 1957. The meteorite findings are from J. R. Cronin and S. Pizzarello, Science (1997), and D. P. Glavin and J. P. Dworkin, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (2009). The idea that one form of thalidomide was harmless rests on work in mice; an earlier study found both forms harmful in rabbits, and the two convert into each other in the body. Soai is paraphrased from his telephone interview with Nobel Prize Outreach on October 7, 2026.

Chemists described but not named: Eilhard Mitscherlich, the German crystal chemist; Willy Marckwald, 1904; K. Barry Sharpless, the 2001 work; Stanley Miller, Chicago, 1953; D. K. Kondepudi, R. J. Kaufman and N. Singh, North Carolina, 1990; Daniel Singleton and Lam Vo, Texas, 2002; the Merck process chemists; Donna Blackmond, John M. Brown and colleagues, the heat measurements, 2001; John Cronin and Sandra Pizzarello, Arizona, 1997; Daniel Glavin and Jason Dworkin, NASA, 2009.

Kenso Soai was born in Hiroshima in 1950; Henri Kagan in Boulogne-Billancourt in 1930. Drafted with Claude Opus 5.5; literary editing by Claude Opus 5.5; outside review by Claude Fable 5.1; copy editing by Gemini Argon (the configured models; the serving model on any turn may differ). Images generated with Gemini Argon from prompts drafted with Claude Opus 5.5.

THE CIRCLE AND THE FLAG

Two nuclear reactors are bound for the moon’s south pole. Neither is coming home.

The Outer Space Treaty forbids owning the moon by claim, by use or by occupation. It says nothing about a ring of ground no one may enter, or about how long such a ring may last. The United States wants its reactor running by 2030; Russia promises one for China by 2036.

Chess makes a distinction the Outer Space Treaty does not. A piece stands on one square and commands others. Games are decided by squares no piece ever occupies, and a player who sees only where the pieces stand will lose to one who sees where they reach.

In late August 2026, NASA asked contractors to prepare a nuclear reactor that could survive the voyage to the moon and run without maintenance near its south pole, the New York Times reported in October. The agency wants it ready to launch by December 2030. Russia, under a partnership with China, has set 2036 for a reactor of its own. The machines are modest. NASA’s would produce about 20 kilowatts, roughly what 16 American homes draw, and Russia’s up to half that. The ground is modest too. NASA named 13 candidate landing regions for its first crewed return in 2022 and narrowed them to nine in 2024, all on a handful of ridges and crater rims near the pole, where the sunlight is nearly constant and the shadowed craters beside them are thought to hold ice. That is the whole prize: a few named places on a body whose surface is larger than Africa.

A reactor at power cannot be approached safely without shielding. On Earth it sits inside a containment building. On the moon, the Times reports, it would more likely sit inside a no-go zone, a ring that neither astronauts nor machines may safely enter. The treaty that governs the moon, signed in 1967, forbids “national appropriation by claim of sovereignty, by means of use or occupation, or by any other means.” Sovereignty, use and occupation are three ways of standing somewhere. The text says nothing about denial. So a handful of the only usable sites on the moon can be made unenterable by acts that break no rule. The one instrument that provides for ending such a zone is not a treaty but a political declaration, signed by one of the two builders and not the other.

And neither reactor is coming home. When a reactor on Earth reaches the end of its life, decommissioning takes years. On the moon, according to Selam Gebrekidan’s reporting in the Times, both NASA and the Russian agencies say they would simply leave the radioactive material behind. The zone will not end when the machine does. In chess, remove a piece and every square it commanded is free at once. The moon is being offered a piece that keeps its squares.

I

Twenty Kilowatts

The reactor NASA wants is small, and nobody has calculated the load. The Times reports that for the first years both programmes need only enough power to keep equipment warm and charge rovers, that solar and radioisotope systems would serve, and that how much electricity a base would need is open to speculation. Two powers are racing to install a power source for a base that does not exist, against a demand nobody has measured. NASA’s machine, as the Times describes it, must work for five years with no intervention; the Russian design, called Selena, for a decade. Neither is a power station. Each is built to carry a base through the dark, and at the pole the dark comes in gaps of a day or two rather than weeks, under a sun that never climbs far above the horizon. That is why both programmes say a reactor must come.

The place is small too. Of the moon’s 37.9 million square kilometres, the parts that matter for a base are the ones where two things meet: ridges high enough to catch sunlight for most of the lunar day, and craters deep enough that sunlight has never reached their floors. The first supply power and bearable temperatures. The second, NASA says, “can preserve resources, including water,” from which oxygen and hydrogen can be extracted for life support and fuel. Such places are few, and they cluster at the south pole. In 2022 NASA named 13 candidate regions for its first crewed landing there, and in October 2024 narrowed them to nine, a short list of massifs, rims and plains whose names will become familiar. Those are landing regions, not reactor sites, which no one has announced. But they are the published evidence of which ground is worth having, and the Chinese-led International Lunar Research Station is aimed at the same pole.

A reactor set on that ground does not command a clean circle. In open space a radiation radius is a sphere. On a crater rim it is cast like a shadow across whatever lies in reach. Set behind a ridge, its reach falls on one slope and not the other. Set near a crater, where the approaches are few, it can cover them. Its zone will be shaped by the terrain it sits in, and so will the question of what the zone denies.

Oblique view of a lunar crater at the south pole: a small reactor with a crown of radiator fins stands on the rim, and a line of lit beacon pylons marks its exclusion zone, running along the rim, down the one gentle slope into the crater and on into the shadow of its floor.
A zone on ground follows the ground: the beacon line runs along the rim, drops down the one slope into the crater and continues into the dark where the floor begins. Generated with Gemini for this essay; it depicts no actual site.

Nobody wanted this yet. A fission reactor is a later need, brought forward. NASA moved its date up because Russia is building one. Russia is building one because China, in the one core task it appears to have delegated, asked it to. Nothing in the record says Moscow set its clock by Washington’s. So only one player is in zugzwang, the position in which the obligation to move is itself the harm, and it is the one bound by the Accords. Every move it has — an earlier launch, a bigger reactor, a looser rule — takes something from the position both sides depend on: a moon that no one owns. The treaty that guarantees it was written for players who stand on squares. The next move puts down a piece that reaches.

II

By Any Other Means

The treaty’s second article is one sentence long. Outer space, including the moon, “is not subject to national appropriation by claim of sovereignty, by means of use or occupation, or by any other means.” Appropriation is the term of art, and it means taking a thing as one’s own. Sovereignty, use and occupation are three ways of doing it: declaring, working, staying. Of the three, use is the widest, and it was put there to catch exploitation that stops short of a flag. A reactor is a use, and a specialist’s first answer will be that a reactor whose radius denies ground is appropriation by means of use. But a radius takes nothing. It makes ground nobody’s rather than somebody’s. The treaty forbids turning the commons into property. It says nothing about turning it into waste. Denial is not acquisition. No claim to any part of the moon has ever been recognized by any state, and no clause of the article mentions keeping others from a part of it.

The ninth article is where the radius enters, and it enters as a duty rather than a loophole. States must conduct their activities “with due regard to the corresponding interests of all other States Parties,” must avoid harmful contamination of celestial bodies, and, where an activity “would cause potentially harmful interference with activities of other States Parties,” must undertake “appropriate international consultations before proceeding.” The duty falls on the state that acts. The builder of a reactor owes due regard to everyone else’s interests, which on a straight reading is a constraint on where it may put the thing. The builder’s answer is that the zone is the due regard: a ring that keeps everyone else safe from what it has built. So one clause both demands the zone and forbids what the zone does, and nothing in the text says which reading governs. The two articles close on each other: obeying the ninth produces the condition the second forbids.

Eight years earlier the Antarctic Treaty had frozen the sector claims that seven nations had drawn across the map of a continent, and the two texts share four prohibitions almost word for word. Antarctica “shall be used for peaceful purposes only,” the earlier treaty says, and forbids “military bases and fortifications,” “military maneuvers” and “the testing of any types of weapons.” The moon treaty repeats all four. But the Antarctic text has a fifth article that the space text does not: “Any nuclear explosions in Antarctica and the disposal there of radioactive waste material shall be prohibited.” An American reactor, SNAP-10A, had already flown, in April 1965, two years before the space treaty was signed, and the treaty says nothing about a reactor stopping.

The law of the sea, drafted fifteen years later, shows what such a rule looks like. Article 60 is not a legal parallel. Its zones sit in waters where the coastal state already has sovereign rights, not in a commons. It is a drafting model, and it shows the two devices the moon’s treaty lacks: a zone with a stated maximum, 500 metres from the structure’s outer edge, and a duty to remove what is finished — installations “which are abandoned or disused shall be removed.” The ice treaty banned leaving the waste. The sea treaty bounded the zone and required removal. The moon’s treaty did neither, no instrument since has set a maximum for a lunar safety zone, and neither programme has published the radius it intends.

III

The Case for the Zone

The case for the reactor begins with the dark. Away from the poles a lunar night lasts about fourteen days, and the pole is not exempt so much as different. The best-lit ground there, by NASA’s own measurement, is lit up to 90 percent of the time, and nowhere on the moon is lit always. A 2010 NASA study found a site near Shackleton crater sunlit about 240 days a year, with its longest stretch of darkness about a day and a half. The sun never rises far above the horizon, so solar panels must stand on edge and are shadowed by the very terrain that makes the site worth having. The radioisotope generators that have powered spacecraft since the 1960s make watts, not kilowatts. An expanded base, the Times reports, would need far more power than those systems can give. On this reading the reactor is not an instrument of policy. It is the answer to a place that is lethally short of energy.

The safety case is nearly as strong. Both NASA and Russia say their reactors will be launched cold, never having been switched on, and the Times reports that nuclear engineers regard cold uranium fuel as posing little radioactive threat even if it tumbles to Earth. The fuel NASA specifies sits below weapons-usable enrichment. On the safety case as its advocates put it, a cold launch materially reduces the risk, and the reactor becomes dangerous only once it is running, on the moon, where no one lives.

The third pillar is the law itself. The Artemis Accords, the political declaration that 59 nations have signed, provide for “safety zones” around lunar operations. The Accords say a safety zone “should be the area in which nominal operations of a relevant activity or an anomalous event could reasonably cause harmful interference,” that signatories “commit to respect the principle of free access to all areas of celestial bodies,” and, at Section 11, paragraph 7(c), that “safety zones will ultimately be temporary, ending when the relevant operation ceases.” The defence writes itself. Nobody is appropriating anything. The zone is a coordination device, published in advance, bounded by function, and gone the day the plug is pulled.

Each pillar holds. The moon is dark, the launch is clean, and the Accords do bind their signatories to free access and to zones that end. Then come the two facts the defence does not survive.

The first is that only one of the two builders has signed the promise. The Accords have no force beyond their signatories, and Russia and China are not among the 59. They are building the International Lunar Research Station outside that framework. The guarantee that a lunar safety zone will be temporary binds the United States and does not touch the other reactor at all. The symmetry of the race is false at the point where it matters: one builder has also signed something the other has not. One has accepted a constraint it may be about to breach by leaving its reactor where it stands. The other has accepted nothing. And the promise itself was drafted with an escape in it. A drafter who meant zones end when operations end does not write ultimately. The adverb lets a zone persist for a very long time while still being called temporary, and it sits in the only sentence in any instrument that says a zone will end.

The second fact is the harder one. Radioactivity decays. A reactor that is switched off stops fissioning at once, but its core stays hot with the decay of its fission products, intensely at first and then less so for a very long time. A spent reactor becomes approachable, by degrees, over decades and centuries. So the zone is not permanent, only long, and a reader who knows this will conclude that the radius has an end after all, and that the end is a matter of physics rather than law.

The answer is not an argument but a place.

IV

Rules for the Wrong Place

There is a body of law for reactors in space. It was written for the sky, and it is written in the grammar of the sky. The Principles Relevant to the Use of Nuclear Power Sources in Outer Space were adopted by the General Assembly on December 14, 1992, as resolution 47/68, fourteen years after a Soviet reactor came down over Canada. Their operative paragraphs on reactors permit three things: operation “on interplanetary missions,” operation “in sufficiently high orbits,” and operation in low orbit on condition that the reactor is afterwards “stored in sufficiently high orbits.” A sufficiently high orbit is one “in which the orbital lifetime is long enough to allow for a sufficient decay of the fission products to approximately the activity of the actinides.” That is the Principles’ entire doctrine of disposal, and it is a doctrine of altitude and time. Put the thing where nothing lives, and wait.

A reactor at the lunar pole satisfies the first half of that rule and inverts the second. It will rest where nothing lives yet, and it will rest there for as long as the orbital rule contemplates. But the orbit the Principles had in mind is a trajectory nobody walks, and the pole is the one piece of ground that both programmes have named as the place they intend to go. The disposal rule for the sky, applied to the surface, produces the radius. The law’s idea of success and the pole’s idea of denial are the same object at a different address.

The Principles are also out of date about the fuel, and out of date in the direction that matters. Principle 3 instructs that “nuclear reactors shall use only highly enriched uranium 235 as fuel,” which in 1992 was the engineer’s choice, because it is lighter and cheaper to launch. Representative Bill Foster, a physicist, told the Times what highly enriched uranium is on the ground: a machine shop and a little high explosive away from a credible weapon. NASA’s documents now specify high-assay low-enriched uranium, which sits below weapons-usable enrichment, and which Russia produces in greater quantity than anyone, and which the United States has banned from Russian sources since 2024. The only rule the United Nations has ever written about the fuel of a space reactor commands the leading builder to do the opposite of what it is doing, and the alliance that has not disclosed its fuel is the one whose older reactors used the fuel the rule prescribes. None of this binds anyone. A General Assembly resolution is a recommendation, and the United Nations working group that Leopold Summerer leads exists to encourage states to follow such rules, not to enforce them.

The Principles are at their most exact on the one moment everyone agrees is dangerous. The United States and Russia say their reactors will be unirradiated until they arrive, and the Times reports that nuclear engineers regard cold fuel as a small radiological threat even if it falls back to Earth. The Principles take the same view and set down what a cold reactor must survive without going critical: “rocket explosion, re-entry, impact on ground or water, submersion in water or water intruding into the core.” A reactor had come down over Canada before the clause was written. Water moderates neutrons; a core that is safely subcritical in air can be critical in the sea; most launch pads stand beside water. “This is the moment when there is a lot of risk,” Summerer told the Times. In October 2019 a State Department official told the General Assembly’s First Committee that a Russian missile which had lain on the bed of the White Sea since a failed test had, when it was recovered that August, produced “the result of a nuclear reaction.” At least five workers died, the Times reports. Russia said the missile was not powered by a reactor. Nuclear experts told the Times that a reactor going critical in water is probably what happened: the event the clause was written to prevent, in the country with more space reactors behind it than any other.

And the law has been tested once on the ground, in the only way it knows. On January 24, 1978, Kosmos 954 re-entered over the Northwest Territories and scattered radioactive debris across a search area of more than 124,000 square kilometres. The cleanup was called Operation Morning Light; it ran through October, and almost none of the fuel was ever found. Canada billed the Soviet Union just over six million Canadian dollars under the 1972 Liability Convention, and the Soviet Union paid about three million. That is the only time international law has been asked what to do when a reactor comes to rest where it should not, and its answer was to price the damage and send an invoice. On Earth a reactor’s resting place is a misfortune and not an asset. On the moon the asset is the resting place. The Convention knows who pays. It has no idea who is owed. Denial of ground in a commons injures nobody in particular, and nobody in particular has a claim.

The law of the space reactor is a law of the moving piece. It knows what the piece must survive on the way, what fuel it may carry and how high it must be parked when its work is done. It has no sentence for a piece that has stopped on the one square everybody wanted, because in the sky the stopping was the solution.

V

What Stays

Chess has one premise so basic that it is never written down: a piece can be lifted. Every rule of the game assumes it. Capture, retreat, resignation, the pieces back in the box; the squares a piece commanded are free the moment the hand closes on it. The reactor is the first piece offered to the moon that the premise does not cover. It will be set down on a named ridge by a lander nobody has yet built, it will run for five years without a hand touching it, and then, by the stated intention of both builders, it will stay. The question is no longer what a piece commands. It is what a piece that cannot be lifted commands, and for how long.

The Earth has answered that question once. On May 2, 1986, six days after the fourth reactor at Chernobyl burned, a Soviet government commission drew a circle of thirty kilometres around it and ordered the whole of it cleared. The circle was drawn by a state that no longer exists. It is administered today by an agency of a state that was not then sovereign, the State Agency of Ukraine on Exclusion Zone Management, and it covers about 2,600 square kilometres, having been enlarged in 1997 to take in ground the wind had reached. The physics of the place has followed the curve the safety case rests on: the short-lived isotopes are long gone and much of the zone is less dangerous than it was. The line has not followed the curve. Forty years on, it is a border with checkpoints, closed to visitors since the invasion of 2022, and the building at its centre is a war target. On February 14, 2025, a Russian drone struck the New Safe Confinement, the arch completed in 2019 to hold the ruined reactor for at least a hundred years; it opened a hole in the cladding and damaged the crane system inside, and the European Bank for Reconstruction and Development puts the repair at a minimum of €500 million, to be finished by 2030. The zone is not permanent. It is only long, and this is what long has meant in practice: a radius that outlived its author, acquired a bureaucracy, became a frontier, and drew fire from a third party in a war its drafters could not have imagined, all because of what stayed at the centre.

Fourteen years before the fire, two Soviet novelists had described something with the same shape. In Roadside Picnic, published in 1972, Arkady and Boris Strugatsky imagined Zones left behind by visitors who stopped on Earth briefly, left their litter, and moved on, and the people who crept in after them were called stalkers. By way of Tarkovsky’s 1979 film Stalker and a 2007 video game, the book’s word became the word for those who enter the real zone without permission. The novel’s title is its argument. The visitors meant nothing by what they left. The zone was not a claim and not an attack. It was the residue of someone else’s convenience, and it governed the lives of everyone who lived at its edge for as long as it lasted.

That is the shape of the thing the moon is being offered. The radius has an end, and the end is a matter of physics, and zones on Earth have in fact contracted as the physics changed. Japan has lifted its Fukushima evacuation orders in stages as dose rates fell, and in August 2022 the order came off part of Futaba, one of the two towns that host the plant. But zones shrink from the outside in, and they have never reached the middle. Fukushima has given back town after town and the plant site remains closed; at Chernobyl the centre is what is under a €500 million repair. What was returned was contaminated ground around a reactor. What was never returned was the reactor.

The lunar zone is a centre with no periphery. There is no dispersed fallout to clean and no farmland anyone wants back; the ring is the asset, the ridge and the approaches and the ice, so the one mechanism by which terrestrial zones have ever contracted has nothing to work on. The lunar zone will be drawn by its builder, under a declaration that promises it will “ultimately” end, or by a builder that has promised nothing, and no instrument names who may draw the second line, the one that says the first has expired. The Outer Space Treaty forbids the flag. It has nothing to say about the circle, and the circle is what stays.

The first reactor is scheduled to stop in the middle of the 2030s, when the second is scheduled to start. Somebody may be standing at the pole then, under one declaration or none, looking at a ring on a ridge that nobody owns and nobody may enter. Whether they call it a precaution or a border is the smaller question. The larger one is whether a place no one can enter is owned, or only lost, and nothing yet written says who gets to decide.

❧

Sources: the reactor programmes, dates, power levels, fuel, launch safety, the White Sea and Kosmos 954 as reported by Selam Gebrekidan, “Superpowers Race to Put Nuclear Reactors on the Moon,” The New York Times, October 4, 2026. Treaty texts read at source: the Outer Space Treaty (1967), Articles II and IX; the Antarctic Treaty (1959), Articles I and V; the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea (1982), Article 60; General Assembly resolution 47/68 (1992), Principles Relevant to the Use of Nuclear Power Sources in Outer Space, Principle 3; the Artemis Accords (2020), Section 11. NASA on Artemis III candidate regions (2022, 2024), on polar illumination (Mazarico et al., 2010; LROC, 2019) and on the moon’s radius. The 2019 State Department statement from Arms Control Today and RFE/RL. Operation Morning Light from The Canadian Encyclopedia. The Chernobyl zone’s establishment, area, administration and closure from secondary reporting, matched across at least two accounts; the New Safe Confinement from the European Bank for Reconstruction and Development at source. Fukushima evacuation orders from Japan’s Ministry of the Environment.

Header and interior images generated with Gemini for this essay. Drafted with Claude Fable 5.1 and Claude Opus 5.5; literary editing by Claude Opus 5; copy editing by Gemini.