Tag Archives: Washaway Beach

WHO OWNS THE FRAME?

Disruptive Design

A house built to move, and a coast where houses always have

NOA’s DeKruif House imagines a home that follows its family from shore to shore. One of the first sites it was drawn for lies at the mouth of the Columbia, where houses have moved before.

“…the people and their planks were simply elsewhere.”Kenneth M. Ames, “Chinookan Plankhouses,” The Oregon Encyclopedia

I The abandoned villages

On 15 November 1805, after eighteen months of walking, paddling and hauling, the Corps of Discovery made camp on the north shore of the Columbia, within sight of the Pacific. Beside the camp stood a village of thirty-six houses, and the captains described it as abandoned. It wasn’t. It was a summer fishing village whose people had gone to their winter homes inland, as they did every year. The explorers took boards from the empty houses to build their own shelters, and from that base Meriwether Lewis went out to Cape Disappointment and carved his name into a tree. On 18 November William Clark found it and carved his own name beside it.

The Chinookan peoples of the lower Columbia built their houses from split cedar planks lashed to frames, and the lashing was the point. In parts of the lower river, a household kept one frame in a winter village and another in a summer one. When the seasons turned, the family untied the walls and the roof and took the planks along. An early ethnography of the Lower Chinook describes them laid across two canoes set side by side, a house afloat in parts. At the other village the planks were tied onto the frame waiting there. Between uses, planks were sometimes sunk in ponds, which kept the cedar from drying out and splitting and drowned whatever was living in it. Ames notes how often early American visitors mistook the bare frames for abandoned settlements. What they were looking at was a house in transit.

Two centuries later an architecture studio from the Italian Alps has designed a timber house meant to follow its owners from shore to shore. One of the two sites it was first drawn for is Ilwaco, Washington, a fishing town on Baker Bay in the lee of Cape Disappointment, a few miles from that camp. The town is named after Elowahka Jim, a Chinook man and son-in-law of Comcomly, the Chinook leader who met Lewis and Clark. By accident or by gravity, the latest version of an old dream has been aimed at the very ground where one of its oldest versions was worked out. Set side by side, the two houses ask a question neither can answer alone. What does a dwelling owe the place it stands on if it does not mean to stay? And whom does it owe: the land, or the people of the land?

II A cairn of luggage

The house is called DeKruif, a Dutch surname that the published material doesn’t explain. It comes from NOA (Network of Architecture), the practice Lukas Rungger and Stefan Rier founded in Bolzano in 2011, best known for Alpine hotels and retreats. As designboom reports, it was conceived for a family that does not want to commit to one location, with one waterfront site in British Columbia and the other in Ilwaco. It is built from cross-laminated timber, thick panels of boards glued together in crosswise layers, the engineered wood that has made timber a serious structural material again. It is prefabricated, so its rooms are made in a factory and arrive more or less finished.

The form is what stops you. Rectangular boxes are stacked, each slipped a little off the one beneath, so the silhouette climbs and leans like a cairn of luggage. Designboom’s report calls it totemic. English borrowed that word from Ojibwe, a language spoken half a continent to the east, and many Northwest Coast Nations do not call their carved cedar poles totems at all. On this coast the word lands with more weight than the report may intend. The whole house is wrapped in overlapping timber shingles with rounded ends. They are really scales, and they make the house look like an animal, a pangolin perhaps, something that sheds water and might curl up if pressed. Circles and half-circles are cut through this hide, and a round skylight at the top opens straight onto the sky.

Then comes the trick: the house barely touches the ground. It stands on slender supports above a base clad in mirror. The mirror reflects the terrain beneath, so the landscape seems to run on under the building without a break. The house comes in three sizes, with 45, 60 or 75 square metres of interior (roughly 480 to 800 square feet). One version rides on the deck of a long boat. It also has a companion piece, DeKruif Island, a round wooden platform with a hot tub, a tree for shade, curved seats and a fireplace at the centre. It is a portable garden for a family that cannot plant one.

Inside, the timber is left bare. A spiral stair threads the stacked rooms. The living space gathers around a suspended fireplace, the bedrooms sit higher up, and a freestanding bathtub faces one of the round windows. Rungger describes a calm interior set against the sculptural shell, a house that swings between open and closed, dark and bright, wet and dry. What he says about the windows turns out to be the key to the design. Instead of throwing the walls open to the view, each opening frames one particular piece of it: “we embrace the panorama by framing it.”

III A house that already lives in pictures

Look through the images NOA has released and you notice something the text never mentions: the house is everywhere. It stands in fog above a lake fringed with reeds, its round windows glowing like the dials of an instrument panel. It sits, tiny, on a vast beach of black volcanic sand, with surf breaking white beside it. It rises among sand dunes and marram grass, with its island-garden set out on the gravel like a dinner plate. It rides out a downpour on a reed-lined river, aboard a hull so long and low it could be a canoe built for giants. It perches above a fjord, in a misty forest, in snow and ice, and in a dry valley with a truck raising dust on the road behind it.

DeKruif House at dusk: three stacked timber boxes clad in dark scale-like shingles, with large glowing round windows, standing on a single slender support above a misty lake fringed with reeds.
DeKruif House, in fog above a reed-fringed lake. Rendering by NOA (Network of Architecture), Bolzano; image courtesy of NOA, as published in Thomai Tsimpou, “prefabricated timber house by NOA is designed to move with its owners,” designboom, November 13, 2026.

These are renderings, not photographs. As far as the published material shows, the house has not yet been built anywhere. That means that as an image it has already done exactly what it promises to do as a building. It has moved, effortlessly and without a single permit, through every landscape a client might want.

Much contemporary architecture is first seen, judged and sometimes only ever known as pictures passed around on screens. DeKruif makes that condition explicit. A house designed to have no fixed address finds its truest form in the rendering, where gravity, soil reports, road widths, bylaws and the neighbours’ opinions don’t yet apply. Even Ilwaco, in that sense, is still a hypothesis.

IV Permanence moves indoors

For most of the history of settled life, the view out of the window was the permanent thing and the room was what changed. A family stayed put. Over the generations it rearranged the furniture, replaced the curtains and knocked through walls, while the hill opposite stayed the hill opposite. Home was a place you looked out from.

DeKruif turns that arrangement around. The rooms stay the same: the same stair, the same stove, the same bathtub in front of the same round window. What changes is whatever fills the window. Here Rungger’s line about framing the panorama takes on a second meaning. A frame that travels is a picture frame, and you can hang it in another room and put a new picture in it. Season after season, the family wakes in the same bedroom with a different world pressed against the glass.

In 1790 a young officer named Xavier de Maistre was confined to his room in Turin for forty-two days after a duel. He spent the time writing a mock travelogue about the journey from his bed to his armchair. Voyage Around My Room is a joke about how much world a small space holds if you pay attention. DeKruif tells the same joke backwards, as a voyage of the room around the world. It assumes that the room, and not the land, is the thing we cannot do without.

The hearth is where that assumption shows. The Latin word for hearth was focus, and DeKruif has two of them, one hanging in the living room and one at the centre of its portable island. Wherever the house is set down, it brings its focus with it. The Chinookan plankhouse did the opposite. As Ames describes it, its fires burned in boxes, in pits or on the earthen floor itself. The planks could travel, but the fire belonged to the ground. The Romans knew a third version of the story. Virgil’s Aeneas carries his household gods out of burning Troy, and the poem follows them across the sea to a coast that already belonged to someone else. Half the Aeneid is the war that follows. A portable hearth always lands somewhere.

V The mirror where the cellar should be

In The Poetics of Space (1958), the French philosopher Gaston Bachelard argued that we imagine a house as a vertical being. At the top is the attic, dry and rational, where the roof shows its reasons and the mind thinks clearly. At the bottom is the cellar, the dark part dug into the earth, where fears live and roots go down. For Bachelard a house is a small cosmology. It connects the sky to the underworld, and it connects the dreamer inside to both.

A cross-section through the ground. On the left, a cedar plankhouse is dug into the earth, with a fire on its floor and a cellar full of round roots below. On the right, a stacked modern house floats on a thin pole above a round mirror that shows only sky.
The cellar and the mirror: a plankhouse dug into the ground, and a house that hovers above it. Illustration made for this essay.

Upriver from the Columbia’s mouth, in the Portland Basin, Chinookan builders made Bachelard’s cellar literal. According to Ames, the plankhouses of the Wapato Valley had cellars or extensive storage pits beneath their floors, a design known nowhere else in Native North America. The largest one excavated, at the Meier site near Scappoose, ran the length of the house and could hold about a hundred tons of wapato, a starchy marsh tuber. Bachelard’s cellar is where roots go down. In these houses it was where the roots were kept. Even at the mouth of the river, where nobody has found such cellars, Chinookan houses were set over or into excavations up to six feet deep. The family lived partly inside the ground.

DeKruif keeps the other end of the axis, its skylight opening the house to the sky, and replaces the cellar with a mirror. Where the plankhouse dug in, DeKruif hovers. It reflects the earth back to the eye instead of entering it, as if nothing had arrived.

Mirrors have been used like this before. In 2017 the artist Doug Aitken built Mirage, a ranch-style house clad entirely in mirror, on a hillside above Palm Springs where lot lines had already been staked for a subdivision. Its walls dissolved into the desert the subdivision would consume, and the subdivision’s developer helped pay for the piece. That makes the mirror look less like a critique than an alibi, a way for a building to seem to vanish from ground it is in the business of claiming.

NOA’s mirror says something gentler, closer to an apology in advance: we were here only lightly, and we will leave. Rungger speaks of blurring the boundary between the built and the unbuilt. It is a guest’s aim, not a resident’s. It belongs to someone who means to be gone before the grass underneath has noticed the shade. On this particular coast, being a guest may be the most honest thing a newcomer can be.

VI Two modern histories

DeKruif’s closest modern ancestor is Jean Prouvé’s Maison Tropicale. In the late 1940s the French colonial authorities commissioned Prouvé to design prefabricated housing for France’s African colonies. He built three prototypes from folded steel and aluminium, light enough to ship by air. One went up in Niamey and two in Brazzaville, raised on steel columns. The houses never went into production. Half a century later, after years of neglect and war, a French dealer tracked them down, and they were taken apart, shipped to France and restored. In June 2007 the large Brazzaville house sold at Christie’s in New York for $4.97 million. The following year it was bolted together again on the lawn outside Tate Modern. A house designed to be sent anywhere ended up in the places where artworks go.

Call that the high road, where mobility signals freedom and the portable dwelling becomes an object of desire.

The other modern history runs through nearly every American town. The mobile home began as the trailer, built to the eight-foot width a car could tow down a highway, and sold to migrant workers and military families who really did move. Then it settled. A HUD analysis of the 2001 American Housing Survey found that three-quarters of manufactured-home residents lived in homes still on their first site. Most of these homes are titled as personal property, like a car, rather than as real estate. An owner whose home stands on rented land owns a house but not the ground under it, and when that land is sold, the house that was supposed to be able to leave usually can’t afford to.

The lower Columbia had worked out a third arrangement long before either of these. The two-frame household had already separated home from place. The planks were the home, and they moved. The frames were the place, and they stayed, held by the family across the seasons and the generations. The mobile-home park is the dark version of the same separation, in which the house is yours but someone else owns the frame. Seen this way, every mobile house raises one question, and it is not whether the house can move. It is who owns the frame.

DeKruif answers that question without ever raising it. It is a house for a family with two waterfronts in mind, people whose problem is a surplus of beautiful places, and they would own the frames, in the form of deeds. The freedom to move is among the most unevenly shared freedoms there are. For DeKruif’s kind of client, mobility is the luxury of never having to choose. The mobile-home owner has the opposite problem: a house that is officially able to move and practically unable to. And for people displaced by war, rent or rising water, moving is no choice at all.

The harder question is whether the idea can cross over. Designboom’s report notes, almost in passing, that the house adapts to each new site only as far as local conditions and building rules allow. Every mobile-house dream runs aground here. We regulate and lend against land as if buildings were permanent, and to a bank a house with no fixed address is a strange and faintly alarming creature. A truly disruptive house would force zoning, lending and property law to treat a home and a place as two things that can be joined and separated, which is roughly what the Chinookan household already did. DeKruif doesn’t solve that problem, but it states it beautifully, in timber.

VII Washaway, and the ark

There is one more reason to take the idea seriously, and it complicates everything above. About thirty miles north of Ilwaco as the crow flies, across the mouth of Willapa Bay, lies North Cove. For most of a century it was the fastest-eroding shoreline on the West Coast, and locals called it Washaway Beach. The sea took a lighthouse, a Coast Guard station and hundreds of parcels of land, most of them family homes.

On a coast like that, the case for a house that can leave looks obvious. Planners speak of “managed retreat,” the orderly withdrawal of settlement from places the sea is going to take, and most of our houses are built so that retreat means demolition. A house that can be lifted, trucked or floated away turns retreat into relocation, and the family keeps its rooms, its stair and its fire.

But relocation needs somewhere to go and someone to pay for the move, and the people of North Cove had neither a second shore nor a timber house on stilts. So in 2016 a cranberry farmer, the late David Cottrell, spent $400 on a truckload of rocks and tipped it onto the beach at the end of a road to see what would happen. The erosion slowed. The experiment grew into a long berm of cobble and driftwood, which engineers call a dynamic revetment, that shifts with the waves and traps sand, and its partners came to include the Shoalwater Bay Indian Tribe and the state Department of Ecology. Ecology’s coastal engineer credits the berm with having largely halted a century of shoreline retreat. The department is careful to add that it is not a permanent solution, and trouble spots remain farther down the beach.

What saved North Cove was a structure designed to move, so that a community could stay. It is the Chinookan arrangement again with the parts recast, loose stones instead of loose planks and the shore itself as the frame. DeKruif offers the opposite remedy, in which the house moves and the shore is given up. That remedy works only for people who have another shore to go to.

NOA’s rendering of the house aboard its long dark boat, with rain pocking the water and reeds along the bank, calls up another timber box, another family, another flood. It has a nearer ancestor too: planks laid across two canoes, crossing the estuary to a waiting frame. The ark is one of the oldest stories we have about a house that moves, and it is the story of a flood, of a world that could no longer be trusted to stay where it was. The ark had room for one family.

VIII What the frame knew

The Chinookan house was mobile, but it was not placeless. Its people moved within a homeland, following a round of seasons between villages whose sites they had held for generations. When they left, they left the frame standing. It was a claim and a promise at once: this is ours, and we are coming back. The skin travelled and the bones stayed home.

The promise was broken, and the breaking was not the Chinook’s choice. Epidemics swept the lower Columbia in the decades after Lewis and Clark, and Comcomly himself died in a fever epidemic in 1830. Treaties signed in 1851 were never ratified, and the land passed to others. When a full-scale plankhouse rose again on the lower Columbia in 2005, at the old village site of Cathlapotle, it was built with the Chinook Indian Nation, which uses it for ceremonies. But it stands on a national wildlife refuge, on land the federal government owns and controls.

DeKruif inverts that. It looks as though it takes everything, frame and skin, hearth and garden, with a mirror at its base so the ground can forget it. It doesn’t. The family would leave behind the lots, the footings, the septic and utility connections and, above all, the deeds. A deed is a frame more durable than cedar. The Chinook kept frames on the beach and lost recognized title to the land beneath them. The DeKruif family would hold title and leave no visible frame.

None of this makes DeKruif a bad house. Judging by the renderings, it is a lovely one: strange, warm, slightly animal, a house that looks as if it has come back from a long journey with stories to tell. Its most radical idea lies beneath the stacking, the shingles, the round windows and even the houseboat. It is the idea that home is a set of rooms rather than a piece of land. The idea is very old and very new, and the lower Columbia shows what it costs. The more completely you can leave a place, the more deliberately you have to choose to return, and the more it matters whether anyone will let you.

The explorers’ misreading did not end with the explorers. When the Bureau of Indian Affairs weighed the Chinook petition for federal recognition, its representatives argued that there was a long gap in the tribe’s history, from about 1880 to 1930, during which it had not acted as a tribe. The federal government recognized the Chinook Indian Nation in 2001. In July 2002 it revoked that recognition, two days after a White House luncheon at which the president asked tribal and government officials to help celebrate the bicentennial of Lewis and Clark.

And yet the people are not elsewhere. The Chinook Indian Nation keeps its offices in Bay Center, on Willapa Bay. On 23 March 2026 the Supreme Court declined to hear its case, and the nation has turned to Congress. Its chairman, Tony A. Johnson, has said that what recognition means to him is “the justice that our ancestors deserved and that our future generations have to have.” It is the frame-builder’s logic, a claim reaching backwards and a promise reaching forwards, put in the language of law.

A few minutes’ drive from Ilwaco, one designer has tried to work on this ground without a mirror. For the Confluence Project, Maya Lin replaced a rusty fish-cleaning sink by the boat launch on Baker Bay with a table cut from a single block of basalt. Carved into its surface is a Chinook origin story, in which the people emerge from the body of a fish that was cut open the wrong way. Lin dedicated the first Confluence site on 18 November 2005, two hundred years to the day after Clark carved his name nearby. When the Cape Disappointment installation formally opened the following April, the Chinook chairman, Gary Johnson, blessed the site in the Chinook language. The same day an Indian activist, Robin Taylor, protested the project on the ground that, as he believes, the Chinook still hold underlying title to much of the county. Lin herself has been modest about what a table can do: “It’s subtle. I hate to preach. But we can give insight.” The table makes no argument. It puts a story under your knife while you clean your catch.

A house that arrives at Ilwaco will not need to leave a marker, because one is already there. The town’s name is a frame left standing in plain sight, carried on its harbour, its streets and its maps. Any family that sets a house down beside Baker Bay will be writing a Chinook man’s name on its deed.

⁂

Sources: Thomai Tsimpou, “prefabricated timber house by NOA is designed to move with its owners,” designboom, November 13, 2026, with Lukas Rungger’s remarks. On the plankhouse: Kenneth M. Ames, “Chinookan Plankhouses” and “Meier Site,” The Oregon Encyclopedia; “Domestic Life,” an ethnography of the Lower Chinook reproduced at chinookstory.org. On Station Camp and Cape Disappointment: National Park Service, Lewis and Clark National Historical Park and Survey of Historic Sites and Buildings; “Discovery awakens Chinook heritage,” The Daily Astorian, February 3, 2005; HistoryLink, Lewis and Clark at Cape Disappointment and “Ilwaco — Thumbnail History.” On Cathlapotle: the Cathlapotle Plankhouse article on Project MUSE and The Columbian, April 12, 2012. On Chinook recognition: “Seeing Clearly,” Center for World Indigenous Studies; “Supreme Court denies Chinook petition for federal recognition,” Underscore Native News and ICT via KNKX, March 25, 2026, with Tony A. Johnson’s remarks; the Chinook Indian Nation’s press release of March 23, 2026. On the Confluence Project: “Maya Lin project nears completion,” Chinook Observer, April 25, 2006; “Cape Disappointment and Maya Lin,” Confluence Project. On Aitken’s Mirage: 303 Gallery press release; Dezeen, February 28, 2017. On Prouvé: “A traveling house,” Stylepark; Tate Modern, 2008. On manufactured housing: HUD, “Manufactured Housing: An Adequate and Affordable Alternative”; Richard Genz, Housing Policy Debate (2001). On North Cove: Washington Department of Ecology, “Caring for North Cove”; “Turning the Tide at Willapa Bay,” Columbia Basin Bulletin, with George Kaminsky’s remarks; Sarah Trent, “This Washington experiment could rebuild eroding coastlines”. Also drawn on: Gaston Bachelard, The Poetics of Space (1958); Xavier de Maistre, Voyage Around My Room (1794); Virgil, Aeneid, Book II. Drafted with Claude Opus 5.5; literary and copy editing by Claude Sonnet 5.5; outside literary review by Claude Fable 5.2. Header and interior images generated with Gemini Argon; rendering of DeKruif House courtesy of NOA (Network of Architecture), via designboom.