Tag Archives: Sergio Leone

THE PHANTOM AT TROY

Clint Eastwood and the old art of taking it back

Stesichorus unsaid one song and got his eyes back. Eastwood has spent forty years unsaying Dirty Harry, and the line the world still quotes from it is one he never quite spoke.

“That story is not true.”

Stesichorus, the Palinode, as Socrates quotes it in Plato’s Phaedrus

I The Blind Poet

Stesichorus of Himera sang that Helen went to Troy, and he went blind. He sang it again the other way, and could see. Three lines of the second song survive, because Socrates quotes them in Plato’s Phaedrus, and they are as plain as Greek gets: That story is not true. You did not go in the well-benched ships. You did not come to the towers of Troy. The Greeks called the poem the Palinode, the song sung back, and kept it as their founding case of an artist withdrawing his own work. The terms were generous. One poem, and his sight was restored.

Socrates tells the story because he is about to try the same thing. He has just delivered a clever speech against love, with his cloak pulled over his head for shame, and he wants it unsaid before the god takes notice. Homer, he observes, slandered Helen too and never understood why he was blind. Stesichorus understood, but only after he had paid. Socrates means to do better than either and recant in advance, this time with his head bare.

That gives three kinds of maker. One never learns what his song did. One learns it from the damage. One takes it back before the bill arrives. Popular artists are almost never the third kind, because a popular work is one that has got away from its author; millions have it by heart before he has thought about it twice.

The Phaedrus leaves out the strangest part of the poem. Other sources report how Stesichorus explained ten years of war if Helen was never there: the gods had sent a likeness, an eidolon, and the armies killed each other over that while the woman herself waited out the war with Proteus, whom the later tellings make king of Egypt. Euripides built a play on the idea, in which Menelaus’s servant, back from Troy, has to be told that he fought for a cloud. As apologies go, it is evasive. The poet concedes nothing about what he wrote. He reclassifies its subject: the Helen of the first song was an image, and the real one was elsewhere all along. Anne Carson built the front of Autobiography of Red around the episode: three appendices on the blinding, the last a deadpan chain of either-or propositions that clears up nothing.

David Bromwich, reviewing Shawn Levy’s biography of Clint Eastwood in the London Review of Books, notices a pattern in the career that he also finds in Dickens and D.W. Griffith: a stretch of unthinking reliance on the audience’s prejudice, followed by what he calls “a dignified retreat.” He gives the pattern a paragraph and moves on. It deserves its old name, and the name carries a question the review has no room for. Stesichorus got his eyes back. Did anyone else?

A blind Greek poet with a lyre faces an empty gunslinger’s coat and hat standing against the setting sun at the far end of a frontier street.
The poet and the phantom. Generated with Gemini Neon for this essay.

II The Lifeguard

Eastwood was drafted in March 1951, nine months into the Korean War, and posted to Fort Ord on Monterey Bay. He had been a strong swimmer since school, and the army put him to work at the post pool as a lifeguard and swimming instructor. He also ran the projector for training films. Other men passed through his pool and went on to Korea. He stayed, and his war consisted of teaching soldiers to keep afloat and showing them pictures of where they were going.

He came close to dying once, and it was an accident of transport. On 30 September 1951 he hitched a ride south from Seattle in a Navy bomber that ran out of fuel and went into the Pacific off Point Reyes. He and the pilot got out before it sank. He swam for the shore lights, climbed a fence, and walked dripping into a radio receiving station, where the lone operator took some persuading. Sixty-five years later, at eighty-six, he directed a film about a pilot who ditches in cold water and is second-guessed for it, and the story he told was another man’s.

So the man who became the world’s picture of someone who shoots first never saw combat. What went to war was a likeness. It was manufactured abroad, in 1964, when an Italian director took a television cowboy to Spain between seasons and photographed him in a poncho with a cigar. Leone shot without sound, as Italian productions did, and Eastwood’s own voice was not laid on until 1967, for the American release. On screen the undertaker calls him Joe. The namelessness came later, from United Artists, whose publicity sold him to Americans as the Man with No Name. Then came Harry Callahan in 1971, who had a name and a badge and the same silhouette.

Eastwood seems to have understood what kind of thing he had made, because he kept casting it as a ghost. In High Plains Drifter (1973), the first western he directed, the stranger who rides in off the desert is, the film all but says, the town’s murdered marshal come back. In Pale Rider (1985) the preacher who comes down from the mountains carries the scars of bullet wounds no man survives. Early in the first of these, three hired guns in the saloon ask the stranger whether he thinks he is fast enough to keep up with them. His hand moves as if to draw and comes up with the whiskey bottle. “Faster than you’ll ever live to be,” he says, and if the film’s hints are right, he can afford the boast because he is not alive.

The exchange of places came in 2008. In Gran Torino, at seventy-eight, Eastwood cast himself as Walt Kowalski, a retired autoworker who did go to Korea, and gave him what the lifeguard had been spared: the killing, a medal he takes no pride in, and the memory of a boy who was trying to surrender. Bromwich reads the film as partly penitential. I would put it more exactly. For forty years an image had done the fighting while the man stayed on shore. Here the man takes the image’s war into his own body, and the body is old.

III A Great Wrong

The clean modern case is Dickens, and it shows both how much a palinode can achieve and where it stops.

Oliver Twist ran from 1837 to 1839. In its first thirty-eight chapters Fagin is called “the Jew” more than 250 times. In 1860 Dickens sold Tavistock House to a banker, James Phineas Davis, and in June 1863 Davis’s wife, Eliza, wrote to the former owner. She asked him to “atone for a great wrong” done to a whole, scattered nation, and she reminded him how much weight his word carried with the English. Dickens answered as authors answer. If Jews thought him unjust, he wrote, they were “a far less sensible, a far less just” people than he had supposed; criminals of Fagin’s class in those years had mostly been Jewish; he meant no disrespect to the faith.

Then he did what she had asked, and more. The novel he was beginning, Our Mutual Friend, acquired Mr Riah, a gentle old Jew made to front for a Christian moneylender, and Riah was given a speech that reads like Mrs Davis’s letter set as dialogue: “Men say, ‘This is a bad Greek, but there are good Greeks. This is a bad Turk, but there are good Turks.’ Not so with the Jews.” He went back into Oliver Twist as well. By the middle of the decade he had halted a reprint and worked through the chapters not yet in type, taking out the epithet, so that in the later chapters Fagin is hardly ever “the Jew” at all. In February 1867 Mrs Davis sent him a Hebrew Bible, inscribed in recognition of a man who had atoned for an injury as soon as he knew he had inflicted it. He replied that her words gratified him more than he could say.

By the rule of Stesichorus that is complete. The injured party named the offence, the artist sang it back, and she certified the cure in writing. Few retractions in literature are so well documented or so decent.

And who remembers Riah? Fagin got Alec Guinness in 1948 and Ron Moody in 1968, with songs. Riah has never had a song. The revised Oliver Twist is odder still, a book that retracts itself nearly three-quarters of the way through, like a speaker who lowers his voice in the middle of a sentence; most readers never notice, because the first thirty-eight chapters have already done their work. Dickens changed the text, wrote the counter-character and earned the letter. His palinode registered, in full, with exactly one reader, the one who had asked for it.

The reason lies in how audiences keep things. They keep a work by saying it, and Fagin is sayable. He has a rhythm, a walk, a toasting fork. Riah has the merit of being fair. The first song travels as cadence and the second as argument, and cadence is faster. An image, once sent to Troy, does not come home because its maker calls.

IV The Counter-Accusation

Bromwich’s second precedent is Griffith, who followed The Birth of a Nation (1915) with Intolerance (1916). I think the pair is better understood as the counterfeit of a palinode, and worth study for that reason.

The two films look like offence and amends. The first celebrates the Klan. The second cuts between Babylon, Judea, sixteenth-century France and a modern American slum to show bigotry destroying the innocent in every age, with a woman rocking a cradle between the stories. Roger Ebert, among others, took it as an attempt to make things right. Griffith said otherwise, and often. After the protests and the local bans he issued a pamphlet, The Rise and Fall of Free Speech in America, and he told interviewers that the new picture was his answer to the people who had tried to stop the old one. The intolerant, in his account, were his critics. The title was pointed outward.

So Intolerance has the outline of a palinode and the content of a rebuttal. “That story is not true” is addressed to the complainants. In Socrates’s scheme Griffith is Homer, the maker who never works out what his song did, with the added talent of turning the injury into a grievance of his own.

Eastwood made his own Intolerance, and made it quickly. Magnum Force came out two years after Dirty Harry, and Turner Classic Movies’ history of the film counts the chance to answer the first one’s critics, Pauline Kael above all, among his main reasons for making it. It sets Harry against a squad of young motorcycle cops who execute the criminals the courts let go, which makes him the system’s loyal servant and puts the fascists in someone else’s uniform. Like Griffith’s title, it points outward. Its catchphrase, which Harry takes from the villain and turns back on him, is “A man’s got to know his limitations.”

Griffith supplies a test, though. A real palinode gives up something the first song had. A counterfeit keeps everything and adds a complaint. Stesichorus gave up the story itself: Helen at Troy was the premise of the Iliad, and he renounced it in his own voice. His sight was the receipt, not the price; the price had been paid in blindness for the first song. The sceptic is entitled to apply the same test to Eastwood, and the case against him is strong on four counts.

The retractions paid. Unforgiven won him the Academy Awards for picture and director, and Gran Torino was the biggest commercial success he had had as an actor. Repentance turned out to be a second franchise.

The retractions also keep the pleasure they deplore. Unforgiven spends two hours establishing that killing is squalid and then delivers the saloon massacre everyone bought a ticket for. Walt Kowalski, before his sacrifice, points a finger at the gang and mimes the shot; the film wants its menace and its remorse together.

The calendar is awkward. Tightrope, the first of his films to suggest that the detective and the killer might be one man, opened in the summer of 1984, eight months after Sudden Impact had given Harry his other famous threat and four years before The Dead Pool sent him out a fifth time. In 1985 a president of the United States borrowed that threat to warn Congress off a tax increase. Eastwood went on drawing on Harry’s account through the years he was supposedly closing it.

And the late work does not retract consistently. American Sniper (2014) is about a man whose kills were counted and who was famous for the count. Sully (2016) is about a pilot who trusted his own reckoning against the investigators’ simulations and was right. In both, the expert did keep count.

Behind all four counts stands a plainer fact. Stesichorus said it in his own voice: that story is not true. Eastwood never has. Asked about Dirty Harry across five decades, he has defended it. There was a Kael, but there is no Mrs Davis: no injured reader who asked for the second song and certified it when it came.

So his palinode, if there is one, is in the works alone. The fair test is to look at them and ask what each gives up.

V The Sixth Bullet

First the offence, since Dickens’s and Griffith’s can be named in a word. Dirty Harry’s is harder to name because it was an argument rather than a portrait. The argument is that the rules protecting suspects are what stand between the city and its killers, and that a good policeman knows who is guilty without them. The film’s district attorney lets the killer go because Harry tortured the evidence out of him, and the audience is asked to side with the torture. Kael called it a right-wing fantasy about a police force unmanned by liberals. The people such an argument injures are the people a policeman is sure about, and in America that certainty has fallen hardest on Black men. The film’s most famous scene puts a wounded Black man on a San Francisco pavement, with a white policeman standing over him. Everything the argument needs rests on one claim: that the man with the gun knows.

Start with what Harry actually says. The robber lies with a gun just out of reach. Harry stands over him and narrates the man’s thoughts for him: was that six shots, or five? He claims to have lost count himself in the excitement. Then he hands the man a question to ask, in the first person, and only then turns on him: “Do I feel lucky? Well, do ya, punk?” The line the world repeats, “Do you feel lucky, punk?”, splices those two sentences into one and moves the question out of the robber’s head and into Harry’s mouth. The public edited out the ventriloquism.

The original is the more disturbing. It is an act of ventriloquism, in which the armed man scripts the inner life of the helpless one and pretends to share his ignorance. Of course Harry has not lost count. When the robber calls after him that he has to know, Harry walks back, aims at the man’s head and pulls the trigger, and the hammer falls on an empty chamber. He has fired six. The doubt is a toy, and the pleasure of the scene is that he knows, and we know he knows. In Dirty Harry power is the ability to fake uncertainty.

He makes the speech twice. At the end of the film, at a quarry, he says it to the killer, and this time the man takes the bet, reaches for his gun, and the Magnum fires. The doubt is feigned both times. The gun is a phantom once and real once, and nobody on the receiving end can tell which until the hammer falls. That is the whole licence the film grants its hero: he alone knows what is in the chamber.

Now follow the doubt through the films that came after.

In Tightrope, which Richard Tuggle wrote and is credited with directing for Eastwood’s company, it moves inside the hero, though only as a tease. The detective hunting a killer of women in New Orleans moves among the women the killer chooses, and one of them is killed soon after he has been with her. For a while neither he nor the audience can be sure where one man ends and the other starts.

In Unforgiven it becomes a creed. The film is dedicated to “Sergio and Don,” Leone and Siegel, the two directors who made the image. Nineteen years earlier Eastwood had put their names on tombstones in the graveyard of High Plains Drifter as a joke, and here he buries them in earnest. A boy who has just killed his first man, and is drinking to stop the shaking, wants to be told the dead man deserved it. “We all got it coming, kid,” says William Munny. Nobody in this film can count who has earned a bullet. Then Munny walks into a saloon and kills the owner, the sheriff and several deputies, and the sceptic’s point about pleasure is made for him.

In Mystic River (2003), which he directed and did not act in, the doubt arrives too late. A father whose daughter has been murdered becomes certain that a childhood friend did it, kills him, and puts the body in the river. The next morning the police have the real killers. Here certainty is the murder weapon.

In Gran Torino the doubt becomes a gesture, and the gesture costs something. Walt stands on the gang’s lawn at night with a cigarette in his mouth and reaches inside his jacket, as that hand has reached inside jackets through forty years of cinema. They fire. The hand falls open on a lighter with a cavalry crest. The gun was the phantom, as it was on the San Francisco pavement, and this time the scene answers Dirty Harry’s ending as well as its opening. At the quarry the wounded man reached and Harry had the last bullet. Here the hero reaches and has nothing, and the other side fires. It is Stesichorus’s move performed by a body: you have been shooting at an image, and the man was unarmed all along. It is also, so far as I can tell, the first time an Eastwood hero chooses to lose the draw. The stranger’s boast is reversed, and he wins by being slower.

Juror #2 finishes the sequence, and Eastwood does not appear in it. He was ninety-three when he shot it. A young man driving home sober from a bar on a night of heavy rain hits something on the road, sees a deer-crossing sign, and drives on. A year later he is seated on the jury that will try another man for the death of a woman found below that road. At the start he does not know what he hit; the trial soon tells him. In the jury room he argues for reasonable doubt. The doubt is true of the defendant and false about himself: it is a guilty man’s knowledge dressed as a juror’s scruple. When the doubt comes too close to him, he drops it, and the verdict comes back unanimous. This is Harry’s trick come back, the knower performing uncertainty, with the guilt moved onto the man who performs it. The question has gone back into the first person, where Harry put it: do I feel lucky? He does. He takes his luck, and a man goes to prison for life. The relentless figure in this film is a prosecutor, and she understands too late. The last shot puts her on the juror’s doorstep. He opens the door, and the picture ends before either of them speaks.

Set the films in a row and the cost the test asks for is there. Tightrope gives up the hero’s separateness from the killer. Unforgiven gives up the idea that the dead deserved it. Mystic River gives up the certainty that vengeance finds the right man. Gran Torino gives up the draw. Juror #2 gives up the hero altogether, and the verdict with him. Violence is still there at the end, and so is law and order; Juror #2 keeps faith with courts that it shows convicting the wrong man, because the process deserves loyalty only if no one in it can be sure. What Eastwood gave up, film by film, was the claim to knowledge on which Dirty Harry’s argument stood: the idea that the man holding the gun has kept count.

VI Sight

Did it work? By the measure Dickens leaves us, it did not. Nothing in Juror #2 will be quoted in fifty years. Its best lines are modest remarks about a flawed system being the best one available, and modesty does not travel. The magnum speech travels, spliced into a form its speaker never quite delivered, so that the Harry everyone carries is a phantom twice over, an image of an image. It is hard to retract a line the audience has already rewritten. Even the stranger’s boast gets clipped in the retelling. The review that prompted this essay runs under the headline “Faster Than You’ll Ever Be,” which drops the two words that make the line a ghost’s: live to.

Turn the boast around, then, and give it to the image. It is faster than he will ever live to be, and he has lived to ninety-six.

But the old bargain was never with the audience. Helen restored the poet’s sight. She did nothing about Greece’s opinion of her, and Homer’s version won. What Stesichorus got for his second song was the use of his own eyes, and by that measure the late films are evidence. The early pictures could not afford to look steadily at a man who is unsure what he has done, or sure of it and unable to bear it; they needed him to know, and to be easy with knowing. The late ones look at little else: a boy sick after a killing, an old man’s hand open on a lighter, a new father on his own doorstep. Each belongs to someone who can no longer claim to have kept count, and the camera stays on them without contempt.

News of his retirement arrived this June in the manner of a phantom. He announced nothing. A remark his son Kyle had made to French television the previous November resurfaced in the week of his ninety-sixth birthday and went round the world as a farewell; some days later another son, Scott, said he had heard no such thing from his father. The man himself stayed on shore, as he did through the Korean War, while a report sailed without him.

Socrates made a point of recanting with his head bare. For sixty years Eastwood’s face was the thing cameras could not leave alone, usually under a hat brim, giving nothing away, and the last palinode does without it altogether. A woman knocks. A man who has bet on his luck opens the door. Nobody has a line.

Stesichorus got his eyes back, and we still call her Helen of Troy.

Sources: David Bromwich, “Faster Than You’ll Ever Be,” London Review of Books 48.21, 26 November 2026, a review of Shawn Levy, Clint: The Man and the Movies (Mariner). Plato, Phaedrus 237a and 242d–243b, in Fowler’s translation; Euripides, Helen 698–745, in Coleridge’s translation; the Stesichorus fragments at Sententiae Antiquae; Anne Carson, Autobiography of Red. The lines of the Palinode are our translation.

On Eastwood’s life and the retirement report: Wikipedia, “Early life and work of Clint Eastwood”; Film Comment on A Fistful of Dollars; Wikipedia and IMDb on the film’s sound and its publicity; Consequence, 11 June 2026.

On Dickens and Eliza Davis: Murray Baumgarten, “The Other Woman,” Dickens Quarterly, 2015; Edgar Johnson, “Dickens’s Apology for Fagin”; Jewish Currents; Wikipedia, “Eliza Davis”.

On Griffith: Wikipedia, Intolerance, citing Paul McEwan and Nicholas Rapold; Michigan Today, “A century after Intolerance”.

On the films: Wikipedia on Dirty Harry, Tightrope, Unforgiven, Mystic River, Gran Torino, American Sniper, Sully and Juror No. 2; Turner Classic Movies on Magnum Force and Dirty Harry; /Film on the ending of Juror #2 and on the tombstones in High Plains Drifter; IMDb on the dialogue of Unforgiven; the Reagan Library for the remarks of 13 March 1985.

Drafted with Claude Opus 5.5 and Claude Fable 5.2; literary and copy editing by Claude Sonnet 5.5; outside literary editing (cold read) by Claude Fable 5.2. The header and interior images were generated with Gemini Neon for this essay.