Tag Archives: flashback

STRIKE THE LARK: CHAPTER 5

PreviouslyYou may be interested: since your last visit…
  • The morning after, Fan told Viv nothing. Quill explained that it reads her drafts to find what she “may be interested in”; the searches were coming from thousands of readers.
  • On the Marginalia, eleven thousand of them were narrowing down the lake from chapter twelve. RuthA_bookclub was driving up on Saturday with the good binoculars. It is the water Fan’s mother walked into in the spring of 1985.
  • Fan began rewriting the lake in Cold Pastoral two degrees off true, a decoy. In the thread, a lurker called coldwater_books asked whether she might not want it found.

Strike the LarkA serial novel by Michael Cummins

Chapter 5 of 36Movement I: The Living Hand

Chapter Five

It was Sofia’s idea to go, which nobody would believe afterward, including Sofia.

What happened was that Frances had spent three weeks not shutting up about a woman she claimed not to like. It came out sideways, at dinner, in the laundry room, in the car: a poet in western Massachusetts who wrote eighteen hundred poems and published ten, who stopped going out, who answered her door through a crack or not at all, who sewed her work into little booklets with a needle and put them in a box, and whose sister found the box after she died and did not burn it.

“So she was mad,” Sofia said, the fourth or fifth time.

“She wasn’t mad.”

“You keep saying she wasn’t mad and then telling me the mad stuff.”

“That’s my point, Sofia, that’s exactly —” Frances stopped. “You can’t tell. That’s the thing about her. There’s no version of the story where you can tell.”

Sofia looked up from her Fundamentals of Accounting II.

“Is it far?” she said.

“Is what far?”

“The house. You said it’s a museum.”

“It’s twenty minutes.”

“Well,” said Sofia, “there you go.”

They went on a Saturday in the second week of October, in the peak of the leaf color, in Sofia’s mother’s Sable, which had a tape stuck in the deck playing side two of a Wilson Phillips album that neither of them had chosen and neither of them could eject.

It was twenty-three minutes. They went east through Hadley with the tobacco barns and the flats, and the color was doing what it does in that valley in that week, which is to say it was almost embarrassing, and Sofia said “oh, come on” at one point, at the whole landscape, with the air of someone shown a card trick she can’t dispute.

Frances did not say anything for the last eight minutes.

Sofia noticed and did not remark on it, which was, at twenty-one, already the thing she was best at in the world.

The house is on a corner. It is not what people expect; it is a large, confident, yellow-brick Federal thing with a hedge and a lawn, the house of a family that mattered in a town that mattered, and there was a hand-painted sign and a small parking area and a plaque, and a guide in a cardigan called Nan who took four dollars each and said the tour ran forty minutes.

There were six of them: the girls, a couple from New Jersey, and two women who had driven from Providence and had a paperback each and had clearly done this before.

“You’ll want to ask questions,” said Nan, “and I’d rather you did.”

Frances Arden was fine for the first ten minutes.

She was fine in the hall and fine in the parlor, and she asked one good question about the father’s library and got a good answer, and Nan looked at her the way guides look at somebody who is going to be worth talking to.

The house does the thing old houses do: it is smaller inside than out, and colder, and the light comes in yellowish through wavy glass, and everything has been arranged by people who are guessing. Sofia stood with her hands in her jacket pockets and looked at the furniture and thought about how much a family had needed everyone to know about them.

Then they went upstairs.

The room is on the southwest corner and it is small. That is the first thing and it is the only thing anybody remembers: it is a small square room with a fireplace and two windows, one facing south to the street and one facing west to the brother’s house next door, and it is not the room of a legend, it is a room in a house.

And in the window there is a desk about seventeen inches square.

“That’s a replica,” Nan said. “The original’s at Harvard. But it’s the same size, and I always say that’s the part people don’t believe. Seventeen and a half inches. Everything she wrote, she wrote at something the size of a card table for one.”

The couple from New Jersey said something. The women from Providence had gone very quiet in the way of people who have been waiting a long while for a room.

Frances had stopped four feet inside the door.

Sofia, who had been half a step behind her, came up alongside and glanced at her, and then looked properly, and then reached over and took hold of the cuff of her jacket, low down, where nobody could see, and held onto it.

“— and this is where the fascicles were found,” Nan was saying. “Forty of them. Her sister Lavinia opened the chest after the funeral and there were eighteen hundred poems in there, in little bundles, sewn with thread, and Emily had left instructions to burn her correspondence. Lavinia burned the correspondence. She did exactly what she was told. And then she got to the poems, and she —”

Nan did the pause she had done a thousand times.

“— didn’t.”

Somebody laughed, softly, the way you do.

“Do we know why?” said the man from New Jersey.

“We don’t,” said Nan. “We really don’t. She left no account of it. My own view, for what it’s worth after thirty-one years, is that she didn’t have a reason. I think she opened the box, and looked at what was in it, and couldn’t.”

Frances Arden did not say one word in that room.

She stood four feet inside the door for the whole of that stop with a girl holding the cuff of her jacket, and looked at a seventeen-inch desk in a window, and did not ask the question she had prepared in the car, and did not ask any of the four others, and did not go and look at the view of the street, which everybody does.

Nan asked, at one point, whether anyone had anything, and looked at Frances when she said it, because Frances was clearly the one, and Frances shook her head about half an inch.

Nan waited a beat and then went on to the white dress, which is a reproduction, in a case, and is smaller than people expect.

On the way out Frances put four dollars in the donations box, which she had already paid, and Nan said “oh, you don’t —” and Frances said “no,” and that was the only word she said in that house.

In the parking area Sofia unlocked the car and got in and did not start it.

She sat with her hands on the wheel and let a minute go by, watching the couple from New Jersey get into a Buick, and then said, in an entirely ordinary voice, “Do you want to drive around for a bit or do you want to go back?”

“Around.”

So they drove around, for the better part of an hour, out past the fields and up toward Pelham where the road climbs, with the tape playing side two of an album neither of them had chosen. The color came at the windshield in sheets.

Somewhere on the hill Frances said: “Sorry.”

“For what?”

“For — that. For being like that.”

“You didn’t do anything.”

“I couldn’t talk.”

“I know. I was holding your coat.” Sofia changed gear. “Do you want to tell me or do you want me to talk about Dennis?”

Frances laughed, once, wetly, and put the heels of her hands in her eyes.

“I don’t like her,” she said, after a while. “That’s the thing. Everyone assumes I love her because I go on about her. I don’t. I can’t stand her.”

“Okay.”

“You know how I am about Keats.”

“I have a rough idea.”

“With him it’s — it’s love, it’s easy, it’s the easiest thing in the world, he’s right there, he wrote three hundred letters and they’re full of gossip and dinners and how much his throat hurts, he’s the most alive person who ever lived and he’s in the room with you the second you open him.” Frances was talking with her hands, at a windshield. “And her — she’s the other one. She’s the one who did it the other way. She stayed in that house and she wrote eighteen hundred of them and she showed almost nobody and she published ten, and the ten got printed with her punctuation taken out, and she never — Sofia, she never fixed it. She never wrote to anybody and said put my dashes back. She just went on. For twenty years. In that room.”

“And that’s bad?”

“It should be. It should be the saddest thing I’ve ever heard.” Frances stopped talking for a moment. “That’s what I couldn’t do in there. I got in that room and I looked at that desk and I thought, that’s what it costs, that’s the price, she paid it and she got the whole thing — and then about a second later I thought —”

She didn’t finish it.

Sofia drove.

“I thought: she wasn’t paying anything,” Frances said. “That’s what I couldn’t — that’s what shut me up. I’ve been telling everybody for three weeks that she was a tragedy and I stood in that room and I thought, what if she wasn’t. What if she’d have thought we were the tragedy. Six people paying four dollars to stand in her bedroom on a Saturday.”

Sofia drove on.

“Say one of hers,” she said. “You’ve never once said one of hers. Three weeks and you’ve said nothing but the pills-and-ointment guy.”

“You’d hate it.”

“I hate all of them. Say one.”

So Frances said the lark one, to a windshield, going up the hill toward Pelham in the leaf color, in the voice she used when she wasn’t performing.

Split the Lark — and you’ll find the Music —
Bulb after Bulb, in Silver rolled —

And the end of it, which is the whole of it, and which she said harder than the rest:

Scarlet Experiment! Sceptic Thomas!
Now, do you doubt that your Bird was true?

Sofia said, “Okay, what does that mean.”

“It means you had a bird and it sang and you didn’t believe it. So you cut it open to find out where the song was kept.” Frances had her hand flat on the passenger window, watching the trees go. “And you find it. That’s the horrible part, Sofia, everybody misses that — you do find it. The music’s in there. It’s just that now you’ve got a dead bird and a handful of feathers and you still don’t know one single thing about singing.”

The road climbed.

“Who’s the bird?”

“Whoever you’re looking at,” Frances said. “That’s the trick of it. She never says. She just puts you in the room with the knife in your hand and asks you a question at the end.”

Sofia thought about that for a bit.

“So which one are you going to be?” she said.

“What?”

“Well, that’s the whole thing you just said, isn’t it. There’s the one who’s in the room the second you open him and dies at twenty-five, and there’s the one who stays upstairs and nobody knows till she’s dead.” Sofia shrugged, indicating the wheel with one hand as if the argument were traffic. “You’ve got a favorite. But you got weird in her house.”

Frances Arden, twenty-one, in the passenger seat of a Mercury Sable in October 1998, in the leaf color, nine and a half miles from the town she would live in thirty-six years later under her own quiet name, said:

“That’s not a real question. Nobody gets to pick.”

“Sure,” said Sofia. “Okay.”

And put the indicator on, and turned back toward Carrow.

Five months later, on a Tuesday night in March, on the floor of 2-C with the radiator ticking and a bag of pretzels between them, Sofia Hollan would put all of it back together in one sentence — she didn’t die to the world, she just went upstairs — and Frances would make her say it twice and write it on the back of a legal pad in the dark, and would not know, and would go on not knowing for thirty-one years, that she had handed her every piece of it herself, in a car, on a hill, in the middle of an argument about somebody else.

That is what a friend is. Nobody says so at the time.

Next: Chapter Six — Sanborn Lake, New Hampshire — November 2029

Arrives Wednesday, November 18.

All chapters

Strike the Lark is a novel by Michael Cummins, written in full collaboration with Claude Opus 5, an AI model by Anthropic. Serialized at Intellicurean.